Mortgage fraud risk rises again as new category takes top spot

Cotality's Matt Seguin on why elevated rates continue to worsen fraud risk

Mortgage fraud risk rises again as new category takes top spot

Fraud risk on mortgage applications climbed again last quarter, and the mix of loans moving through the pipeline is a large part of the reason.

Purchase loans, which carry more documents to alter than a refinance, dominate the market due to the elevated rate environment. The loan types that carry the most fraud risk are growing.

The category with the biggest year-over-year increase involves the property itself, taking the lead from undisclosed real estate debt after a few months out front.

Matt Seguin (pictured top), senior principal of fraud solutions at Cotality, said the company's National Mortgage Application Fraud Risk Index rose 5.8% to 139 in the third quarter of 2026, up from 132 in the second quarter and 3.5% above a year earlier.

Cotality estimates 1 in 112 applications showed indications of fraud risk, and the index had already climbed 9.1% in the second quarter.

"As the refis go down, purchases go up, the fraud risk inevitably goes up," Seguin told Mortgage Professional America.

Elevated rates equal elevated risk

Economists forecasted gradually falling rates in 2026. However, rates have remained elevated instead. Seguin does not expect rates to fall in 2027 either, although he said nobody can know for sure.

Government streamline refinances, which often skip appraisals, asset documents, and income documents, leave little for a fraudster to alter, he said. Those are the loans that have been fewer and farther between in the current rate environment.

"Purchases, you don't have nearly the leeway to avoid all those documents, and just the odds go up," Seguin said.

Overall applications fell 11.3% from the second quarter to the third, while purchases made up 71% of applications and government-backed loans about 24%.

Investment and multi-family loans rose to 13% of volume from 12%. The company estimates 1 in 42 investment applications and 1 in 27 multi-family applications show indications of fraud risk, against 1 in 112 overall.

"You kind of have the riskiest segments growing, the least risky segment in refis dropping, purchases are riskier than average, and so that's growing," Seguin said.

Property fraud risk, which covers intentional misrepresentation of a property or its value, posted the biggest year-over-year increase at 2.3%. It overtook undisclosed real estate debt, which rose 1.4%.

Cotality's alerts rose in three areas. They included possible flips in higher foreclosure markets with rising prices, invalid Social Security numbers and address histories that do not match a borrower's credit file, and first-time buyers purchasing investment properties.

Valuations differ sharply from market to market, Seguin said, and purchase activity is slowing in many of them.

"You wait 30, 40 days and you get one offer, and it's 5% below list price," Seguin said. "And maybe that's a little disappointing."

Cotality said the property increase is not surprising given a deeply divided real estate landscape.

"When you start looking at valuation and any kind of fraud, motivation comes into it somewhere," Seguin said. "And so as that happens, or maybe it's on a cash-out refinance that now you didn't get that appraised value that you expected, there starts to become a little more risk for overvaluation."

AI, patterns and new products

Document alteration with AI is something that keeps coming up with clients, Seguin said. He recalled one catch from the subprime crisis.

"A lot of the human telltale signs of document identification are gone," Seguin said. "I remember looking at a bank statement, and it said ‘Withdrawal maid in store,’ and it was spelled M-A-I-D, and it was one of the big banks. And I knew, ‘Okay, that is not how they're going to spell the word made.’ And AI's pretty much taken that away, and those kinds of little signals that underwriters are used to looking for."

Seguin has been a proponent of stepping back to look for patterns in the data, such as a loan officer whose loans all do the same thing.

"Every pay stub in this whole batch, they all use the same format. And there are 20 different employers here. What are the chances of that?" Seguin said. "It's going to be harder to identify on a one-off loan basis."

Non-agency loan types bring their own exposure, from DSCR loans, where borrowers are often LLCs and conflicts of interest can go undisclosed, to bank statement loans, which open the door to bank statement fraud.

"From an agency perspective, you have a black-and-white guidelines regulator with Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, and lenders are being audited regularly, and the non-agency space doesn't necessarily have that today," Seguin said.

While new technology is working hard to identify signs of mortgage fraud, Seguin warns that fraudsters are also hard at work using the same new tech to find new ways to create fraud.

"Anytime you have a new product or a new technology, the fraudsters are often a step or two ahead of us, and they're going to find a way to take advantage of it," Seguin said.

Stay updated with the freshest mortgage news. Get exclusive interviews, breaking news, and industry events in your inbox, and always be the first to know by subscribing to our FREE daily newsletter.

RELATED ARTICLES