NAMB president Farrell on Capitol Hill arguing fee increase will be 'damaging' and math 'is just flawed'
Mortgage broker advocates are on Capitol Hill today trying to stop a provision that would nearly triple the fee on VA streamline refinances before it reaches the president's desk.
The provision is part of a sweeping veterans benefits bill that the House passed last week by voice vote and that now awaits action in the Senate.
Michael Farrell (pictured top), president of the National Association of Mortgage Brokers (NAMB), said the group is meeting with Senate Veterans' Affairs Committee Democrats today. He is also a mortgage originator who says 58% of his business is VA loans, a Navy veteran and the father of a combat veteran.
"These veterans raised their hand and took an oath to serve our country and defend our country," Farrell told Mortgage Professional America. "They didn't put their hand out to receive an invoice to pay for their brothers and sisters' fallen and hurt benefits."
Section 104 ‘going to be damaging’
Section 104(b) of the Take Care of America's Veterans Act would amend the VA loan fee table, according to the bill text, to raise the interest rate reduction refinance loan (IRRRL) funding fee from 0.50% to 1.42%. It would also raise the loan assumption fee from 0.50% to 1.0%.
On a $400,000 refinance, the IRRRL increase adds $3,680 to the fee, according to Military Times. Lenders closed 119,457 IRRRLs nationwide in fiscal year 2025 and 207,416 in fiscal year 2026, according to VA loan volume data.
"It is going to be damaging, and the math is just flawed," Farrell said.
The bill's backers expect the higher fee to help pay for expanded veterans benefits, and Farrell said NAMB supports those benefits on their own. His objection is where the money comes from.
"They are predicated on the funding raise off of the backs of the VA IRRRL loans when 51% of VA IRRRL loans are exempt from funding fee," Farrell said.
Veterans who receive compensation for a service-connected disability are generally exempt, which, by Farrell's figure, leaves roughly half of the volume to carry the increase.
An IRRRL also has to show a net benefit to the borrower, Farrell said, and the new fee would stretch the break-even point past 60 months, against the 36 months VA requires a refinance to recoup its costs.
"This market environment is not conducive to doing an IRRRL," Farrell said. "The rates would have to be down in the low 6s, possibly high 5s to be able to accommodate those net benefits."
Carlos Scarpero, mortgage broker at Edge Home Finance, told Mortgage Professional America after the bill was first introduced in June that most of the IRRRLs he had closed over the previous year likely wouldn’t have closed with these changes.
"A lot of these loans that I've done, most of them probably would not have closed if that bill had been in effect last year," Scarpero said. "All these veterans that could have saved $200, $300, $400 a month, you're basically tripling the funding fee. That would certainly cause some problems.
"You still got the recoup rules, and I'm totally in favor of that rule. It's pretty common for an IRRRL to be at like 12 to 18 months on the recoup. That could easily throw it over the 36 months. Some loans will work, but a lot won't."
An alternative, in Farrell's view, is returning funding fees across the board to levels from two years ago, a 15 basis point adjustment that would not single out one group of veterans.
"You're not alienating any segment of veterans from one status of veteran to another," Farrell said.
Pushing the Senate
The House passed the bill, H.R. 9237, on Veterans Day, Nov. 11. The Senate companion, S. 4744, was introduced by Senate Veterans' Affairs Committee Chairman Jerry Moran, R-Kan.
Moran has said he supports the House-passed package, while Sen. Richard Blumenthal, D-Conn., the committee's top Democrat, has said he cannot back its proposed benefit cuts, according to The New York Times. Those cuts are separate from the fee increase.
NAMB has held meetings and table discussions with Senate Veterans' Affairs Democrats, Farrell said, and has four or five appointments with legislators this afternoon, plus events this evening.
"We do not feel it's too late," Farrell said.
The timing adds uncertainty, he said, because the bill is moving in the lame duck period after the midterm elections.
"How it happened last week in regard to a verbal vote is just not typical," Farrell said. "At this point right now, the challenge that we have is that it's not traditional processes over the next 45 days, and how much is going to be pushed through."
The House also passed the Major Richard Star Act, a separate bill on combat-injured veterans' retirement pay, 392-18 on Nov. 12, and both measures now await the Senate.
"Which one's going to be the one that sticks?" Farrell said. "Hopefully just the independent Richard Star that we support."
Brokers can send a letter to their senators through NAMB's advocacy page in about five minutes, he said, with the group's position papers attached.
"Their input, their action, their involvement is needed more than ever right now for our veterans," Farrell said.
NAMB is also offering itself as a resource to lawmakers looking for a middle ground, he said.
"We definitely have a pathway," Farrell said. "We just need to get to the ears of the folks to take a moment and listen to the whys."
Stay updated with the freshest mortgage news. Get exclusive interviews, breaking news, and industry events in your inbox, and always be the first to know by subscribing to our FREE daily newsletter.