HSBC runs out the clock on its own Brooklyn foreclosure case

A five-year delay in adding a necessary party cost the bank the case

HSBC runs out the clock on its own Brooklyn foreclosure case

A New York appeals court just handed HSBC Bank USA a loss in a Brooklyn foreclosure - not on the merits, but on timing. 

The Appellate Division, Second Department, reversed a lower court decision on November 12 and dismissed the bank’s amended complaint against a subsequent property owner, ruling the six-year statute of limitations for mortgage foreclosure actions had already expired by the time HSBC moved to bring him into the case. 

The timeline is what sinks this one. HSBC filed its original foreclosure action in February 2015 against the borrower on the mortgage, targeting a Brooklyn property. The borrower never appeared and never filed an answer. The court granted an order of reference in January 2019, and an order and judgment of foreclosure and sale followed in December 2019. 

The problem was that the borrower had already conveyed the property by deed in August 2014 - months before HSBC even filed. That deed was recorded in April 2015. But HSBC did not move to add the new owner as a defendant until February 2020, nearly five years into the litigation. 

The court granted HSBC’s request to file and serve a supplemental summons and amended complaint in a September 2022 order. Service then hit its own trouble. HSBC obtained court permission to serve the new owner by publication and was required to publish the supplemental summons in two designated local newspapers. It published in one on time. It missed the deadline on the second. 

The new owner filed an amended answer in September 2023 raising several defenses, including the statute of limitations and lack of personal jurisdiction due to improper service. He moved to dismiss the amended complaint in November 2023. HSBC cross-moved for additional time to complete service. The lower court sided with the bank, denying the dismissal motion and granting the time extension. 

The appellate court saw it differently. 

Under New York law, a lender has six years to bring a mortgage foreclosure action. The original complaint was filed in 2015. The amended complaint adding the new owner came after that window had closed. The new owner met his burden of showing the claim against him was untimely, and the burden shifted to HSBC to raise a question of fact that it was not. 

HSBC’s argument rested on the relation-back doctrine - a mechanism that allows a plaintiff to add a new party after the limitations period expires, provided the new claim arises from the same facts, the new party shares a legal interest with the original party, and the new party knew or should have known the action would have included them but for a mistake in identifying the right parties. 

The court found HSBC failed to establish the doctrine applied. The argument that the new owner and the borrower shared identical interests fell apart because the borrower had defaulted. He never appeared, never answered. Courts have consistently held that a defaulting party’s interests cannot be treated as aligned with a newly added defendant for this purpose. 

That finding ended both questions. Because the action was not timely commenced against the new owner, the court held it lacked authority to extend HSBC’s time to serve him. The dismissal motion should have been granted. The time extension should have been denied. The court did not reach the new owner’s remaining arguments. 

The service-by-publication miss compounded the problem but was ultimately beside the point. Once the statute of limitations barred the claim, no extension could rescue it. 

For servicers and foreclosure counsel, the practical takeaway is narrow but costly: when a borrower conveys a property during - or before - a foreclosure action, the lender needs to identify and add the new owner promptly. In a jurisdiction with a hard six-year window, waiting years to do so can mean losing the case with a judgment already in hand.