What brokers should look for in a non-QM lending partner

One broker says the wrong one can turn an easy deal into a nightmare

What brokers should look for in a non-QM lending partner

As more borrowers bring non-traditional income sources to mortgage transactions, more brokers and originators are turning to non-QM loans to close loans that won’t work with agency lending.

With an increase in non-QM customers comes an increase in non-QM lenders. Some are new companies that have opened to meet the increased demand, while others are existing companies working in the non-agency space for the first time.

The question is how to figure out which companies are good fits for brokers’ non-QM loans, and which ones might be less than ideal.

Jacy Bloom (pictured top), owner and mortgage broker at Bloom Mortgage Solutions, said she sorts lenders into those that specialize in non-QM and those that dabble in it, and she puts a lender's process ahead of its rates.

Non-QM makes up most of her business, and she’s seen the trouble when a lender doesn’t specialize in non-agency loans.

"It was miserable for me," Bloom told Mortgage Professional America. "It was miserable for my clients. They overcondition everything because they still write the loans like a conventional lender."

Lenders that dabble in non-QM

About one in four broker pricing searches on Optimal Blue's Loansifter platform in September was for non-QM loans. In October, 12% of production and 17% of lock volume was non-QM loans, up 420 bps year-over-year. Lenders that want a share of that volume call Bloom often, including ones whose main business is conventional.

"I get calls from lenders all the time, and I'm like, you're either non-QM, or you're QM," Bloom said. "They just try to be a jack of all trades. And I don't think you can be good at everything. Kind of the same thing with brokers."

One of her loan officers wanted her to sign up with a particular lender, and she did. He put a DSCR loan with them and sent her the condition list that came back.

"This is the most insane condition list that I've ever seen for a DSCR, except when I tried to put one with a QM lender," Bloom said. "I was like, ‘Please pull the loan, put it with one of the lenders that I work with all the time.’ And he did, and he closed it easily."

Non-QM appeals to her because it gives borrowers another way to get financing, she said. She wants lenders that treat it as a specialty.

"These lenders are competitive, and they're good loans," Bloom said. "People always say that they're risky, but they're really not at the end of the day. They're just a different way to qualify."

She does not do reverse mortgages or USDA loans, and she sends complicated VA loans to people she trusts with them. Bloom said she would rather those borrowers be taken care of properly.

"I have great people I can refer them to that will take care of them, and then I can focus on what I'm good at," Bloom said. "So that's kind of how I look at lenders too."

What she looks for

When comparing lenders to find the right fit for a non-QM loan, Bloom believes it is process over rate, especially if the rates are relatively competitive.

"Their process, obviously, that's just number one,” she said. “Obviously, they need to have good rates and everything and good pricing. But I'd say that's number two, because at the end of the day, the majority of them, the rates are pretty similar. I'm not going to put my client through hell to save them an eighth of a point rate."

A friend of Bloom's used an out-of-state bank that took a month to find that his condo would not work for a conventional loan. By then, his rate had risen by a point.

"The person he was working with wasn't educated enough, and it's ridiculous that it took them a month to figure this out," Bloom said. "That's not fair to the client."

Pricing still varied on one recent investment loan. Bloom priced it with a couple of non-QM lenders and got a range of answers.

"Some of them were half a point higher than where I ended up placing the loan," Bloom said. "But obviously I have the options to put the loan where I want."

Past process and price, Bloom wants underwriters who use judgment and an account executive (AE) on the lender's side. She would rather not build a file around exceptions.

"I look for process, smooth process, good communication with everybody, common sense underwriting, lenders that can give an exception when one's needed," Bloom said. "I don't try to automatically go in with needing exceptions. I'd rather work with a lender that just will accept the deal as it is, because that just makes it cleaner. Obviously having a good AE on their team of the lender is really the most important thing."

Stay updated with the freshest mortgage news. Get exclusive interviews, breaking news, and industry events in your inbox, and always be the first to know by subscribing to our FREE daily newsletter.

RELATED ARTICLES