Jack Gilbert on negative leverage, motivated sellers and escrows with a 'dramatic' challenge
Despite high borrowing costs, new data released Wednesday by the US Census Bureau showed multifamily housing starts surged in October.
However, the overall picture is a little more complicated. While multifamily starts rose 25.5% from September, permits for the same properties fell 5.2%.
In addition, numbers released Tuesday from the National Association of Home Builders (NAHB) showed builder confidence fell to its lowest level since 2012.
In existing buildings, though, stabilized multifamily deals have slowed, and the gap between what sellers hope for and what buyers will pay is a big part of the reason.
Many of those buildings were bought in the cheaper-debt years with thin or negative leverage, and with plans to hold them for a long time.
One commercial broker said sellers are hoping for one buyer willing to pay a premium, which is causing issues in the multifamily market.
Jack Gilbert (pictured top), a multifamily broker at Radius Commercial Real Estate in Santa Barbara, California, sells mostly on the Central Coast, across Ventura, Santa Barbara and San Luis Obispo counties. He said the slowdown this year is concentrated in stabilized trades.
"Every seller, and rightfully so, wants to capture that 1031 buyer, the miracle buyer that's going to come in and pay the price that they're willing to pay," Gilbert told Mortgage Professional America. "But as we know, that doesn't always happen."
Why stabilized deals are stuck
Value-add buyers are still around for the right deal. A stabilized building on the Central Coast trades at a 5.5 cap rate, maybe a 6 cap in certain submarkets, according to Gilbert.
"Which at this point is negatively levered," he said. "And it's hard for people to get their head around unless they're all cash and they have to move the money."
In the cheaper-debt years of 2020 through 2022, exchange money and wealth poured into real estate, and some of it went into stabilized buildings in luxury locations like Gilbert's. Those buyers did not expect rates to rise in the next few years.
"They were buying these stabilized deals negatively levered or slightly positively levered, and just planning to hold on to them for a longer period of time," Gilbert said.
Stabilized trades now happen mostly with 1031 exchange buyers or investors who have to move money, which has split the buyer pool in two.
"There's almost two different markets right now," Gilbert said. "The one stabilized buyer that's just buying at a good yield and has faith that the market's going to increase over time. And then there's the other buyer, which is everyone's lucky favorite buyer as a broker, is the 1031 buyer that's willing to sometimes even overpay in comparison to the market to get the type of product that they're looking for."
A lot of the sellers Gilbert works with are not the traditional yield-based syndicators or private equity groups that sell to capture a return on a building bought five or ten years ago.
"They're not at the point where their property is worth a significant amount more than what they bought it for," Gilbert said.
Motivated sellers and dramatic escrows
Some of Gilbert's clients are done with California, and many think their money is better spent elsewhere. Owning and operating multifamily property in the city of Santa Barbara is extraordinarily difficult, he said.
"Here it might take five years to break ground on a project that's going to cost three times as much as if somebody wanted to move their place to Idaho and build three times, four times the amount of units for the same cost and do it much quicker," Gilbert said.
For commercial brokers in other markets, Gilbert said the key to finding deals comes down to finding sellers who have expectations grounded in reality.
"I don't know if this is the best advice, but this is what's helped us, is working with sellers who are realistic and not spending an atrocious amount of time with sellers that just simply aren't going to achieve what they're setting out to achieve," Gilbert said. "If you're working with a seller that isn't truly motivated in this market, it's very futile. And there's just not the large swath of a buyer pool for you to be a non-motivated seller."
Credits are where the thin buyer pool shows up once a property is under contract. Gilbert said most of his team's escrows over the last year hit a serious snag.
"Because the buyer pool is so thin, if your seller's truly motivated, there's just a lot less leverage in negotiation when it comes to credits," Gilbert said. "The majority of escrows that we've had in the last year, there's been some type of dramatic challenge that we've had to overcome to get the deal non-contingent and come across the finish line."
Market conditions have developers hesitant as well. Gilbert met with a larger developer three weeks before the interview who was unsure it was the right time to build.
"They're worried they're not going to be able to raise the money or that when they raise the money, they're not going to be able to achieve the rents that they're looking to underwrite to," Gilbert said.
Stay updated with the freshest mortgage news. Get exclusive interviews, breaking news, and industry events in your inbox, and always be the first to know by subscribing to our FREE daily newsletter.