A three-day trial, 65 pages, and a contract clause that hinged on one word
One accounting entry pushed a REIT’s equity below a contract threshold, halving its former manager’s termination payout. Delaware’s Chancery court reversed it.
Vice Chancellor issued the ruling on November 13, 2026, after a three-day trial. The 65-page opinion delivers a mixed verdict in a dispute between a real estate investment trust's (REIT) former management company and the REIT itself - with practical implications for anyone structuring management agreements around equity milestones.
The setup traces back to 2010. Four founders formed a cluster of entities to acquire commercial properties leased long-term to federal government tenants. By 2016, the structure included HC Government Realty Trust - a Maryland corporation operating as a REIT - its Delaware holding company, HC Government Realty Holdings, and an external manager, Holmwood Capital Advisors.
Under their management agreement, Holmwood was entitled to asset management fees equal to 1.5% of the REIT’s stockholders’ equity, acquisition fees of 1.0% per property deal, and a termination fee if the REIT ended the arrangement. That termination fee equaled three times the sum of management and acquisition fees earned over the prior 24 months.
A side letter later modified the formula with equity-linked thresholds. If stockholders’ equity never reached $15 million, no termination fee was owed. If it reached $15 million but not $35 million, the fee was halved. Cross the $35 million mark, and the full 3.0x multiplier applied.
In March 2019, the REIT’s board approved a recapitalization with a new investor, Hale Partnership Capital Management, voted to terminate the management agreement effective March 31, 2020, and installed new leadership.
The new Chief Financial Officer (CFO) initially calculated stockholders’ equity above $35 million for the first two quarters of 2019 - $35,916,217 for Q1 and $37,133,134 for Q2. But when she prepared financial statements for an SEC filing later that year, she and the REIT’s auditors concluded that Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP) required accruing the estimated termination fee as a liability on the books. Recording that $1,750,000 estimate dragged stockholders’ equity for Q2 2019 from $37,133,134 down to $34,904,007 - just below the $35 million line. Every calculation after that stayed below the threshold, and the REIT calculated the termination fee using the lower 1.5x multiplier.
The court ruled this was wrong. Under the management agreement’s definition of stockholders’ equity, non-cash items that impacted GAAP-reported equity had to be excluded. The termination fee estimate was exactly that - a non-cash accrual. No cash changed hands until March 2020. The estimate had to be added back.
The REIT tried two more angles. First, it argued that dividends had been improperly added back to stockholders’ equity in prior calculations - meaning equity never actually reached $35 million even without the termination fee estimate. Second, it claimed the properties contributed to the holding company in 2017 were overvalued by roughly $3.2 million, inflating equity from the start.
The court rejected both on waiver grounds. On dividends, the REIT’s own CFO knew the calculation methodology included them, used that exact method in the final termination fee notice sent to Holmwood on March 31, 2020, and did not raise the issue until a June 2025 expert report - five years later. On valuation, the REIT’s appraiser made what the court called “obvious errors,” including accounting for the COVID-19 pandemic in a 2017 valuation and applying vacancy deductions to properties that were never vacant.
The side letter says the multiplier depends on whether the REIT “builds” stockholders’ equity to certain levels. Holmwood argued “builds” means “achieves” - a high-water mark. The REIT argued it means “maintains,” so if equity later fell below $35 million, the lower multiplier would apply. The court sided with Holmwood. The word carries no temporal limitation, and adding one would mean rewriting terms the parties never agreed to.
Result: the 3.0x multiplier governs. The parties were directed to jointly recalculate the termination fee.
Holmwood did not sweep the board. The court applied the doctrine of contra proferentem - where ambiguous terms in a contract are read against the drafter - to rule that the REIT could pay the termination fee and acquisition fees in common stock without the manager’s input on the form of securities. The founders had drafted the management agreement while sitting on both sides of the table, then marketed the REIT to outside investors. The court held they bore the burden of making the terms clear.
Holmwood also lost on acquisition fees for three properties the REIT purchased in October 2019 for a combined $17,272,766. The management agreement tied those fees to specific services - identifying investments, arranging purchases, coordinating closings. The management company’s own CEO conceded at deposition that it did not provide those services for the disputed acquisitions.
On counterclaims, the court found Holmwood breached the contribution agreement by failing to obtain lender consent before transferring interests in three properties financed under a CMBS loan. The lender was never informed of the 2017 exchange transaction and issued a notice of default in November 2022. The REIT spent $517,463.35 negotiating a consent and loan modification agreement, reached in March 2023, and the court awarded that full amount in damages.
The REIT also succeeded on offering expenses. A side letter capped reimbursable organization and offering expenses at 15% of gross proceeds from the REIT’s Regulation A offering, which raised $8,871,660. Expenses exceeded the cap by $723,932, and the court ruled Holmwood must cover the excess.
The REIT’s claim that Holmwood caused it to pay $76,322 in duplicative property management fees failed for lack of evidence. An unjust enrichment counterclaim based on the alleged $3.2 million overvaluation also failed, since the court found the properties were not overvalued.
Separately, $408,514 that Holmwood transferred to the REIT between May 2017 and April 2018 to cover operating shortfalls remains unpaid. The court found Holmwood did not prove the transfers were loans with specific interest terms, but the REIT does not deny receiving the money. The parties were directed to propose repayment terms.
For REIT operators and anyone structuring management agreements around equity milestones, the case makes the practical point plainly: the equity formula you use in your termination notice is the formula the court will hold you to, and GAAP-driven accruals do not automatically override a contract’s own definition of stockholders’ equity.
The court directed the parties to meet and confer on a proposed order implementing the rulings. Final figures for the termination fee, asset management fees, offering expense repayment, and shortfall amounts remain to be calculated.