Katherine Stagg on improving protection conversations during the mortgage process
Katherine Stagg (pictured top) has spent more than 20 years in financial services, but it was an October evening at Financial Reporter's Women's Recognition Awards that crystallised what she has built.
Named Protection Adviser of the Year, Stagg – founder and managing director of Stagg Mortgage Services, a family-run firm in Sheffield – did not arrive at the ceremony chasing recognition. She arrived as someone who had long believed protection deserved better, and found that the industry was beginning to agree.
"I never set out to win awards," Stagg told Mortgage Introducer. "I've always just tried to do the right thing for clients and make sure that when we arrange a mortgage, we're also having the conversations about what happens if life doesn't go to plan."
Stay ahead of the UK mortgage market. Subscribe to the Mortgage Introducer daily newsletter for broker news, rate updates, and the industry latest delivered to your inbox every morning.
Family first, advice second
The family-run ethos at Stagg Mortgage Services is not branding. It shapes the advice process from the first client conversation. Stagg describes a simple test she applies when preparing for a protection discussion. If the person sitting opposite her were her daughter, her husband, someone she loved, what would she want them to understand?
"That changes the conversation completely," she said. "It becomes much more human, and I think clients can feel that."
Protection conversations, Stagg argues, should not be about frightening clients or ticking a compliance box. They should be about understanding somebody's life – their income, their mortgage, their children, what would actually happen financially if they became seriously ill, could not work, or passed away.
Why do so many advisers still treat protection as an afterthought?
Stagg is direct about where the industry still falls short, and timing is at the centre of it. The prevailing model – close the mortgage, then introduce protection – hands advisers a client who has mentally completed the journey. By that point, cover can feel like another product and another monthly cost rather than an integral part of the financial plan.
Her view is that the protection conversation must begin at the fact-find – the initial information-gathering stage of the advice process, where an adviser establishes a client's income, outgoings, dependants and financial commitments. If an adviser is asking what mortgage payment a client can comfortably afford, they should simultaneously be asking what happens to that payment if the client cannot work, becomes seriously ill, or dies.
"It shouldn't be, 'Great, we've got your mortgage offer. Now shall we talk about protection?'. By then the client has mentally completed the journey," Stagg said.
That instinct is backed by data. The Association of Mortgage Intermediaries’ (AMI) Protection Reimagined report found that only around half of advisers raise protection at the beginning of the client interview, suggesting the industry's timing problem remains widespread.
Stagg sees this partly as a process failure. Mortgage cases are complicated, advisers are under pressure to get applications submitted and offers through, and protection can slip to the end of the queue. The answer, she argues, is not better intentions but better processes that embed protection into the journey from day one.
What is holding income protection back?
The numbers on income protection are stark. According to data from Royal London, only 7% of UK adults hold income protection, compared with 32% for life insurance – a gap Stagg describes as one of the industry's most persistent failures, and one that sits at the heart of the debate over Britain's protection gap.
Part of the problem, she believes, is how the product has been sold. Life insurance is conceptually simple. If the client dies, their family receives money. Income protection – a policy that replaces a portion of a client's earnings if they are unable to work due to illness or injury – requires a different conversation, asking somebody to think about what happens if they are still here but cannot earn.
"If your salary stopped tomorrow, how long could you continue paying everything as you do today?" Stagg said. "That makes it real."
She is also keen to challenge the perception that income protection is automatically expensive. Modern policies can be shaped around individual circumstances, with different deferred periods – the waiting time between a client stopping work and the policy beginning to pay – and payment periods available.
Royal London's current personal income protection offering can cover up to 65% of the first £60,000 of pre-tax earnings across a range of deferred period options. The focus should be on selling the outcome – protecting the income that supports a client's life – rather than leading with technical language that creates distance from the decision.
Consumer Duty and the advice file
The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) has explicitly named mortgage completion as a natural trigger point for protection conversations and has pressed advisers on their Consumer Duty obligations. Compliance, in Stagg's view, should not mean more paperwork. It should mean demonstrating that clients have genuinely understood their risks, their options, and the consequences of their decisions.
"The ultimate customer outcome isn't that we've got a perfectly completed file," she said. "It's that the customer understands what could happen financially and has been given a genuine opportunity to do something about it."
The FCA's pure protection market study final report concluded that the core problem is consumer understanding rather than commission structures or restricted panels – a finding Stagg regards as a validation of the case advisers have long been making.
AMI's research found that six in 10 consumers had never received a protection quote, while 72% had never even started the protection journey. Stagg is also alert to the risk of treating a client's initial reluctance as a final answer. The same research found that between 79% and 95% of people who dropped out of the protection journey said something could have changed their decision.
Raising the standard collectively
Being named one of the Income Protection Task Force's 7Advisers gave Stagg direct exposure to how peers across the industry approach the same conversations. The experience reinforced a conviction she already held. There is no single script for a good protection conversation, but there is a consistent discipline, making it relevant to the individual, grounding it in their actual circumstances, asking the questions that prompt real thinking.
She is conscious that visibility carries responsibility. Awards and industry recognition are only useful, she argues, if they translate into raising practice across the board. The Elite Women 2026 report highlighted the growing influence of women across the mortgage sector – a shift Stagg embodies as a business founder who has grown her firm while championing protection as a professional discipline, not an afterthought.
"I never want protection to become something where we celebrate individual advisers but don't improve what we're doing collectively as an industry," she said. "The more advisers who have good protection conversations, the more families we protect. That has to be the goal."
Want to be regularly updated with mortgage news and features? Get exclusive interviews, breaking news, and industry events in your inbox – subscribe to our FREE daily newsletter. You can also follow us on Facebook, X (formerly Twitter), and LinkedIn.