A broker she knew only as 'Lee' allegedly set the whole thing in motion
An 84-year-old League City, Texas, woman has sued the lender, servicer, and trustee behind a $351,000 cash-out refinance she says she was tricked into signing - on a home she owned free and clear.
The lawsuit, filed November 16 in the US District Court for the Southern District of Texas, names MCM Holdings, Inc. (doing business as MCM Capital Solutions) as the lender, Newrez LLC (doing business as Shellpoint Mortgage Servicing) as the servicer, and Wilmington Savings Fund Society, FSB, as owner trustee for Verus Securitization Trust 2024-1, the entity that holds the loan.
The borrower, who is representing herself, alleges she bought her home at 2170 Santa Cruz Lane in 2018 with proceeds from selling rental properties and owned it outright before a loan broker she knew only as "Lee" began managing her finances around 2020.
A broker working under aliases
According to the filing, the broker contacted her using multiple names and email addresses tied to a string of company names, including Pointe Funding, First Class Business Group, Green Capital, and Premier USA Funding. The suit says he told her he was acting in her best interest, that the companies he worked with would give her a good rate, and that if her loans defaulted, his attorney would handle the lawsuits and he would cover the costs.
The filing alleges the broker gained access to the borrower's email and bank accounts, sent messages from her email as if he were her, deleted her messages and emptied her email trash folder, and handled the proceeds of loans he arranged against her home and her store. What the lawsuit describes is a cycle: the broker allegedly arranged one merchant cash advance after another through funders in New York and elsewhere, and when one could not be repaid, he arranged the next - collecting broker fees along the way.
The suit says the borrower lost hundreds of thousands of dollars to online scammers while the broker was communicating in those same messaging applications and deleting the exchanges.
How the refinance came together
By September 2023, the filing alleges, the broker was receiving the borrower's home records and forwarding them to one of his own email addresses. A mortgage brokerage - identified in the filing as a non-party - arranged and processed the home loan through a submissions mailbox, according to the suit.
On October 16, 2023, MCM Capital Solutions issued a Loan Estimate for a 30-year fixed-rate refinance of $351,000 at 10.75%, with monthly principal and interest of $3,276.52 and an estimated total monthly payment of $4,245, the filing states. The loan was categorized as "Other - Non-QM," meaning it fell outside the federal qualified-mortgage rules that come with built-in protections for both the borrower and the lender on ability-to-repay compliance. The final Closing Disclosure raised the total monthly payment to $4,658.87, according to the suit.
The filing alleges the loan replaced a 5.99% PrimeLending mortgage and an Amegy Bank home-equity line, and that the borrower did not have the recurring income to keep up with the new $4,658.87 monthly payment on top of her existing debts and living expenses.
The underwriting questions
The suit lays out what it calls warning signs that went unaddressed during underwriting. It alleges the lender's processor asked for invoices to show that large bank deposits - including $29,625 from OnDeck Capital, a business lender, on June 14, 2023, and two wire deposits totaling $69,010 in July 2023 - were business income. According to the filing, those deposits were not business income at all. They were borrowed money from merchant cash advance funders that the broker and his associates had induced the borrower to take on.
The suit further alleges the underwriting communications passed through a third-party submissions mailbox, that the borrower's file and the lender's conditions were answered by associates at that mailbox, and that the broker used her email account to speak in her name throughout the process.
What happened at closing
According to the filing, the borrower signed the deed of trust on November 14, 2023, at a law firm in League City, at an appointment the broker arranged. The closing instructions identified the loan as a 30-year, 10.750% owner-occupied first-lien cash-out refinance with an appraised value of $540,000 and a first payment due January 1, 2024, the suit states.
The filing alleges the Closing Disclosure was dated November 8, 2023, but its receipt lines were unsigned and undated - raising questions, the suit says, about whether the borrower received the final itemized breakdown of charges at least one business day before closing, as Texas law requires for home-equity loans. The Closing Disclosure allocated just $492.32 in cash to the borrower, according to the suit, while total closing costs consumed $22,461.58 and payoffs to prior lenders totaled $328,696.10.
The filing also alleges the closing costs exceeded the two-percent fee cap that the Texas Constitution imposes on home-equity loans by $124.84, and that the Closing Disclosure's contact columns for "Mortgage Broker" and "Settlement Agent" were left blank - even though a brokerage handled the loan and a settlement company closed it.
The suit says the borrower never received the separate federal notice of her right to cancel the loan, as required by the Truth in Lending Act.
Default and foreclosure threats
Shellpoint began servicing the loan on January 1, 2024, according to the filing. The servicer reported a principal balance of $351,000 and an escrow balance of $5,529.40 at transfer.
The filing alleges Shellpoint placed lender-purchased insurance on the loan in October 2024 and later cancelled it. The suit notes that in August 2026, Newrez entered a multistate settlement agreement and consent order with state mortgage regulators - including the Texas Department of Savings and Mortgage Lending - over noncompliance with the federal lender-placed-insurance rule. That order required Newrez to audit lender-placed-insurance fees on newly boarded loans from January 1, 2023, through its effective date and to refund borrowers for erroneously placed coverage, according to the filing.
On January 15, 2026, the suit says, Shellpoint sent a certified-mail default notice demanding $8,713.27 by February 19, 2026, and warning that failure to pay "will result in acceleration of the sums secured by the Security Instrument and sale of the property."
The borrower's funds were depleted or unavailable to her, and the broker held access to her bank accounts, the filing alleges. On November 6, 2026, Shellpoint notified her by email that it had no record of her mortgage payment and that the account was past due, according to the suit.
Rescission and what comes next
On November 10, 2026, the borrower revoked in writing every power of attorney and other authority she had given the broker, the filing states. She mailed a rescission notice by certified mail on November 14, 2026, to MCM Capital Solutions, MCM Holdings, the trustee, and Shellpoint.
The suit asks the court to declare that the lien on her home is invalid under the Texas Constitution's homestead protections and that any foreclosure would need a court order. It also seeks to cancel the loan under the Truth in Lending Act, claims MCM failed to make a good-faith determination that the borrower could repay the loan, and demands a full accounting of every payment, fee, escrow charge, and insurance transaction from origination to the present. The borrower is also asking for a preliminary injunction to block any non-judicial foreclosure sale while the case plays out.
For lenders and servicers, the case is a reminder that non-QM origination through broker channels - especially where underwriting communications pass through third-party mailboxes - carries compliance exposure from the ability-to-repay determination all the way through to Texas fee caps and disclosure-timing rules.
None of the allegations in the lawsuit have been tested in court, and no judge has ruled on any of the claims.