'Tracker mortgages are still competitive, but the gap has closed' – broker

Rhys Edwards on rate uncertainty, borrower confidence, and the global forces shaping the UK mortgage market

'Tracker mortgages are still competitive, but the gap has closed' – broker

Tracker mortgages are still undercutting fixed rates on monthly payments, but the gap is closing fast, and for many borrowers, the risk calculus is shifting.

Rhys Edwards (pictured top), head of mortgages at Stratton Wealth Management in Manchester, says renewed client interest in trackers is being tempered by rising tracker margins and a base rate outlook that nobody, including the banks, can call with confidence.

A tracker mortgage ties a borrower's interest rate directly to the Bank of England base rate, meaning monthly payments rise and fall in line with the central bank's decisions. Unlike fixed-rate mortgages, which lock in a rate for a set term, trackers offer no payment certainty, but they typically start lower. The Bank of England raised its base rate to 4% on 5 November – its first increase in over three years – meaning borrowers on tracker products saw an immediate 25-basis-point rise in their monthly costs.

The National Institute of Economic and Social Research (NIESR) has since urged the Bank to go further and raise rates to 5%, warning that inflation will not return to its 2% target until late 2030 on current policy, with the Moneyfacts average new mortgage rate reaching 5.89% in November – up from 5.83% the previous month.

It is against that backdrop that Edwards is fielding a growing number of calls from clients weighing up their options. "Trackers are certainly still lower," he told Mortgage Introducer. "When clients come to me for renewals, they're standing out still. But the gap has closed. A lot of the tracking rates have increased because the base rate has gone up, and some banks have increased their tracker margins a little bit since the base rate increase as well, so it has made them a little bit less attractive."

Edwards says the picture varies by loan-to-value bracket, and that client appetite for risk remains the decisive factor. Some of his investment clients are prepared to accept the uncertainty in exchange for lower monthly payments. Others are not – and why brokers should be discussing tracker mortgages right now with every renewing client is a question the industry has been wrestling with throughout 2026.

"My job is just to make sure they're aware of the risk and what could happen, because the honest answer is we don't know," Edwards said.

Stay ahead of the UK mortgage market. Subscribe to the Mortgage Introducer daily newsletter for broker news, rate updates, and the industry latest delivered to your inbox every morning.

Managing expectations in a shifting market

Beyond the tracker question, Edwards says the broader challenge right now is managing borrower expectations, particularly among first-time buyers who have been rattled by rate movements but are starting to re-engage with the market. Data collated by Yorkshire Building Society shows that first-time buyer applications have dipped as home movers retreat further, with affordability pressures reshaping activity across all buyer types.

"I've seen quite a lot of new enquiries coming through, people kind of thinking about getting on the property ladder," he said. "The rhetoric I try to go with is, let's speak to you well in advance before you even start to think about looking at properties. Let's give you some ideas and budgets."

The most common question Edwards receives – “is now a good time to buy?” – rarely has a clean answer. His approach is to provide context rather than prescription, walking clients through the long-term history of interest rates and challenging the assumption that current levels are historically extreme.

"A lot of people just looked at interest rates as being very, very low, and then think that rates are now extremely high when, actually, they're not," he said. "They're higher than they have been, but not as high as they have been."

He also highlights an underappreciated consequence of the rate environment – softer property prices in some areas, which he describes as a double-edged sword.

"The knock-on effect is that you can potentially buy a property for a little bit less than you could have bought it six months ago in certain areas," Edwards said. "So you go into the finances and ask, what are you paying in rent per month? Well, the mortgage is still going to be less than your rent, and you're going to be owning something."

A volatile outlook driven by global forces

On the rate outlook, Edwards is candid about the limits of anyone's foresight, including the banks themselves. He believes another base rate increase is likely before the picture stabilises, but sees significant uncertainty beyond that.

Financial markets are increasingly confident of a December hike, but 64 of 65 economists polled by Reuters expect the Bank to hold steady at its 17 December meeting before hiking again in February 2027, but much will depend on the November inflation reading and whether energy price growth is spreading into other areas of the economy.

"I think it is highly likely we're going to have another base rate increase before anything else settles," Edwards said. "What happens after that, even the banks themselves don't really seem to know. Some are indicating we may not see much more of an increase after that, but it all depends on a lot of things."

Geopolitical tensions, he argues, are a significant and underappreciated driver of that uncertainty. US foreign policy and its effects on oil prices remain a live variable with direct implications for inflation – and, in turn, for mortgage pricing. Oil prices have remained above $100 a barrel since July, up from around $70 in early 2026, with UK gas prices more than tripling since February as a consequence of renewed conflict in the Middle East, according to NIESR's Autumn Economic Outlook.

"America's having a massive impact," Edwards said. "Their policies with Iran and elsewhere are still having a massive influence on the price of oil. Hopefully peace is going to be the big change, because for the mortgage industry, it will certainly help get inflationary pressures down on energy and fuel, which will hopefully lower prices for mortgage providers."

Want to be regularly updated with mortgage news and features? Get exclusive interviews, breaking news, and industry events in your inbox – subscribe to our FREE daily newsletter. You can also follow us on Facebook, X (formerly Twitter), and LinkedIn.