Trust rose in every sector, but mortgages gained only 0.4 points
Mortgage borrowers are the least trusting banking customers in the UK, according to the Autumn 2026 Trust in Banking Index from consumer group Fairer Finance.
Mortgages scored 58.47%, the lowest of the five sectors surveyed and well below savings accounts at 66.02%. Trust rose in every sector among the 10,000 banking customers polled, but mortgages gained only 0.4 points, against about 1.4 each for current accounts and credit cards. Mortgages are also the only sector where the trust gap between struggling and financially comfortable customers is widening.
The scores are not the share of customers who trust their provider. Fairer Finance subtracts negative responses from positive ones and double-weights the strongest opinions, so each figure is a net balance of trust and distrust.
Why income splits mortgage trust so sharply
Borrowers with a household income of £20,000 or less give their lender 48%. Those earning more than £70,000 give 62.2%. That gap of more than 14 points is the widest income gap in any sector. In the others it runs from under one point for savings to 7.6 points for personal loans.
Rate type matters too. Fixed-rate customers score their lender 60.46% and variable-rate customers 52.23%. The survey does not test causes, but exposure is the obvious candidate. A fixed rate locks the payment for two or five years, while a variable-rate payment moves with each Bank Rate decision, and borrowers tend to hold the lender responsible for the bill. Lower-income households also have less spare income to absorb a rise.
The timing sharpens the point. The Bank of England raised Bank Rate to 4% on 5 November 2026, its first rise since August 2023. That lifts payments quickly for variable-rate borrowers, and UK Finance projected about 1.8 million fixed-rate deals would expire in 2026, so many more borrowers will move onto higher rates.
James Daley, managing director of Fairer Finance, said many customers are about to see monthly payments rise while they are already dealing with higher energy and petrol costs. He also noted that many savers are not seeing higher rates passed on, so borrowers should expect banks to protect them rather than keep all the gains.
What credit card repayment habits reveal
For the first time, Fairer Finance asked credit card customers how they repay their debt. Those who clear the balance each month give their provider 64.47%. Those who pay more than the minimum but never clear it give 50.95%. Customers who only ever make the minimum payment give 33.65%, a gap of more than 30 points.
The data shows a correlation, not a cause, and it probably runs both ways. A customer who clears the balance pays no interest, so the card is simply a free payment tool. A minimum-only customer carries debt, pays the most interest and sees the provider’s pricing every month. Many are likely under financial strain.
The implication is that a provider’s score partly reflects who its customers are. Mortgages show the same effect inside a single lender. Santander’s variable-rate customers score it 40.6%, while its fixed-rate customers give it 56.96%, a gap of more than 16 points. Santander also fell 1.72 points to 54%, the lowest among the big lenders. A lender with more stretched or variable-rate borrowers will rank lower whatever its service is like.
Trust follows how often customers use the bank
In current accounts, financial strain matters more than income. Customers who find their bills a heavy burden score providers 53.71%, against 68.53% for those who do not. Monzo is the most trusted among struggling customers at 75.64%, ahead of Nationwide at 71%. HSBC scores 37.85% with this group, the lowest of the larger providers.
Nationwide tops current accounts for the second wave running at 77.39%. It is also the most trusted big mortgage lender at 67.33%, ahead of Lloyds Bank at 65.16%.
Daily use may explain part of the pattern. A current account is used every day, usually in an app. A mortgage is dealt with at purchase, at renewal and when rates move, which is often when the news is bad. Lenders get fewer chances to build trust and more moments to lose it.
Trust also has commercial value. The implication for lenders and brokers is that the borrowers who trust least are also the least likely to disclose difficulty, so firms will need to identify them through data and early contact, as the Financial Conduct Authority's (FCA) Consumer Duty expects. Daley said: “It’s important that banks do what they can to support borrowers and offer competitive deals in this economically challenging time."
Want to be regularly updated with mortgage news and features? Get exclusive interviews, breaking news, and industry events in your inbox – subscribe to our FREE daily newsletter. You can also follow us on Facebook, X (formerly Twitter), and LinkedIn.