The bank never properly served three minor children. It cost them the case
Bank of New York Mellon just lost a foreclosure - not because of the debt, but because it took too long to serve the papers.
New York’s Appellate Division, Second Department, affirmed the dismissal of the bank’s foreclosure action on a Valley Stream residential property on November 18, 2026. The case had been open since 2013. The court found the bank never properly served the borrower’s three minor children and blew its default judgment deadline against her husband.
The borrower executed a loan agreement and note secured by a mortgage on the property in September 2004. She died without a will on February 22, 2010, survived by her husband and three daughters, all minors at the time.
The bank filed its foreclosure action on May 13, 2013. A process server claimed to have served the children by delivering papers to a person of suitable age at their home. Under New York law, though, serving a minor requires personally serving a parent or guardian - not just leaving documents at the door.
By November 2022, the bank had obtained a court order clearing the path toward default judgment. Then, in December 2023 - more than ten years after filing - it finally moved for an extension of time to properly serve the children.
The family cross-moved to vacate the 2022 order and dismiss the case. The trial court sided with them. The appellate panel agreed.
On the children, the court found two independent failures. The bank never showed “reasonable diligence” in attempting service and offered no credible excuse for the decade-long delay. The original service was also jurisdictionally defective - the husband was served individually, not in his capacity as the children’s natural guardian, as CPLR 309 requires. Without proper service, the court had no jurisdiction over them at all.
On the husband, the problem was different but the result identical. Under CPLR 3215(c), a plaintiff that fails to seek default judgment within one year of the defendant’s default risks dismissal. The bank missed that deadline, and its explanations were, in the court’s words, “conclusory and legally insufficient.”
The panel was unanimous.
For servicers and default teams, the takeaway is blunt: a valid debt and a valid mortgage mean nothing if the foreclosure paperwork cannot survive a motion to dismiss.
This decision is based on a slip opinion, uncorrected and subject to revision before publication in the Official Reports.