A broken promise, three apartment complexes, and not a dollar in damages
An investment firm proved a real estate developer broke an exclusivity agreement. It still walked away empty-handed.
The Delaware Superior Court, in a post-trial opinion issued October 27, 2026, found that Toro Real Estate Partners and its co-founders breached an exclusivity clause in a letter of intent with Davenport Investments. Toro had agreed to give Davenport an exclusive seat in a joint venture to acquire three multi-family apartment complexes in Jacksonville, Florida. Instead, Toro’s co-founders cut the investor out and closed the deals themselves.
The breach finding turned out to be hollow. Judge Meghan A. Adams ruled Davenport failed to prove it suffered any damages - and ordered it to return a $100,000 due diligence deposit to Toro.
The dispute traces to early 2019. Toro had agreements to purchase three Jacksonville apartment complexes - River City Landing, Whispering Oaks, and Highlander. Davenport, an investment firm focused on multi-family commercial real estate, approached one of Toro’s co-founders looking for investment opportunities. The two sides signed a letter of intent in March 2019 for a joint venture in which Davenport would make a preferred equity investment, with the rest of the acquisition funded by a loan.
Most of the LOI’s terms were explicitly non-binding - a detail that would prove decisive. But one provision was binding: Section 7, the exclusivity clause. It barred Toro from pursuing any alternative deal that would “replace all or part of” Davenport’s investment.
Negotiations broke down within days. Davenport raised concerns about whether the lender financing the Whispering Oaks and Highlander purchase had properly approved the proposed ownership structure. By March 15, 2019, Davenport refused to approve the proposed loan. It also paused drafting of the joint venture agreement - a task the LOI had assigned to Davenport - and sent a sweeping new due diligence request just two weeks before the first scheduled closing.
That same evening, one of Toro’s co-founders emailed a third party: “we want to get davenport out of the deal you free for a quick call?” The next day, the other co-founder called a Davenport principal to say Toro was moving forward without them. A written cancellation of the LOI followed on March 24.
Toro closed on Whispering Oaks and Highlander on March 29, 2019 - all-cash, because the loan was not ready - and on River City Landing on May 8, 2019.
Davenport sued in April 2019, first seeking a preliminary injunction in the Delaware Court of Chancery to block the River City Landing closing. The court denied the motion but found a colorable claim. The case later transferred to Superior Court after the Court of Chancery determined it lacked jurisdiction - Davenport was chasing money, not equitable relief. Trial took place in October 2025.
Judge Adams found the breach straightforward. By terminating the LOI and closing the acquisitions without Davenport, Toro had entered into exactly the kind of “alternative transaction” the exclusivity clause prohibited.
Damages were a different matter entirely.
Davenport pursued expectation damages - the profits it claimed it would have earned from the joint venture. The court rejected that theory. The LOI declared most of its provisions non-binding, so it was not a final agreement. Under Delaware law, it fell into a third category of preliminary agreement - one that does not, as the court put it, “nail down enough of the final deal” for lost-profit damages to be calculated with any certainty.
The court identified what it called a “chicken-and-egg paradox”: Toro’s termination made it impossible for Davenport to invest, which ensured the contemplated transaction never closed. But Judge Adams found Davenport’s own conduct made the damages argument unsustainable regardless. Davenport had paused drafting the joint venture agreement, refused to approve the loan, never committed to fund the deal, and sent its sweeping due diligence request two weeks before closing.
Vice Chancellor Glasscock had flagged this exact problem at an earlier summary judgment hearing: “the deal never happened. It didn’t happen in that manner. It happened in a different manner. I don’t see how you get anything but reliance damages out of it.”
Davenport presented no reliance damages theory at trial. No legal bills. No expense reports. No evidence of out-of-pocket costs at all.
Toro fared better on its counterclaim. Under the LOI, Toro had paid Davenport a $100,000 deposit to cover due diligence costs. The agreement required Davenport to refund any unspent portion if the LOI was terminated. Judge Adams drew a critical distinction: the termination itself was not wrongful - only the subsequent closing without Davenport breached the exclusivity clause. So the refund obligation had already kicked in.
When a Davenport principal was asked at trial whether Davenport had any evidence of out-of-pocket costs from due diligence, the answer was no.
Toro’s separate abuse of process counterclaim failed. The court noted the earlier court had found a colorable claim, and losing a motion does not make it an improper one.
For real estate professionals structuring joint ventures, the lesson is practical: an exclusivity clause can protect your seat at the table, but it cannot protect your profits if the final deal was never locked down - and if you cannot document your costs, you may end up returning the deposit, too.
The case is not yet fully resolved. Judge Adams directed the parties to brief attorneys’ fees and interest under the LOI.