Sustained pressure on profitability is pushing more than a third of mortgaged landlords to refinance within 12 months
More than a third of landlords with buy-to-let (BTL) mortgages plan to refinance at least one property over the next 12 months, according to ModaMortgages’ analysis of research from Pegasus Insight. The figure sits at 38% — and it has not moved far from that level in a year and a half. Before mortgage rates began rising in 2023, it was closer to three in ten.
What is different now is why landlords are doing it. More than half of those surveyed said their portfolios are less profitable than five years ago. That is not a niche complaint from a handful of struggling landlords; it reflects how the economics of BTL have been reshaped by rate rises, rising running costs, and successive waves of regulatory change. When the mortgage is the biggest single cost in the portfolio, reviewing it stops being optional.
Portfolio landlords, multiple cases
Almost half (46%) of landlords with four or more BTL mortgages plan to refinance during the next year, against 30% of those holding between one and three. That gap matters because portfolio landlords don’t come in with one transaction. The research found that landlords planning to refinance expect to review an average of nearly three mortgages each. A single client conversation can quickly become a complex, multi-property exercise.
Becki Fraser-Tucker, Head of Sales at ModaMortgages, said: “For landlords with several mortgages, refinancing can quickly become a sizeable exercise. A simple and transparent process matters, especially where the aim is to replace existing borrowing rather than raise additional funds.”
That distinction of replacing existing debt rather than raising more is worth noting. Many of these landlords are not looking to expand. They want to move an existing balance onto a new deal, ideally without friction. Fraser-Tucker called this a “pound-for-pound remortgage,” which provides a clear route forward for landlords who simply want to swap onto better terms.
Profitability is the pressure behind the numbers
Low profitability is the context in which the refinancing intent sits. Landlords are not refinancing because conditions are favourable; they are refinancing because costs have risen and the mortgage rate is one of the few variables they can still act on.
It also explains why the intent has stayed elevated. Rather than a one-off response to the rate rises of 2023, refinancing has become a standing item on landlords’ agendas — something they are actively managing rather than putting off until a lender sends a renewal letter.
Fraser-Tucker said: “Refinancing should not be viewed as a box-ticking exercise at the end of a fixed term. It’s an opportunity for landlords and their brokers to check that the finance remains appropriate for the property and the landlord’s plans, while ensuring the process itself is as smooth and straightforward as possible.”
That framing has implications for how lenders and brokers position themselves. A landlord reviewing profitability across several properties is a different client to one simply rolling onto a new rate. Lenders are being judged on the criteria that matter most when volume and complexity arrive together: service, consistency, and clarity on what they will and will not lend on.
Analysis from The Mortgage Works, based on CACI’s Mortgage Market database, projects that in 2027, 35% of BTL market balances will mature, with the remortgage and product transfer market forecast to rise 45% compared to 2026. With landlords already signalling their intentions this far ahead, the question for the market is less whether the volume is coming and more whether the process is ready to handle it.
Fraser-Tucker added: “The research shows that refinancing is relevant to landlords with a wide range of portfolio sizes and ownership structures. In my view, the strongest propositions will be those that keep the journey clear, provide certainty over the criteria and make it easy for brokers to establish whether a straightforward remortgage is the right fit.”
Want to be regularly updated with mortgage news and features? Get exclusive interviews, breaking news, and industry events in your inbox – subscribe to our FREE daily newsletter. You can also follow us on Facebook, X (formerly Twitter), and LinkedIn.