Mortgage industry pushes back on calls for BoE to raise base rate to 5%

Industry figures argue higher rates cannot fix an inflation problem driven by global energy shocks

Mortgage industry pushes back on calls for BoE to raise base rate to 5%

The National Institute of Economic and Social Research (NIESR) caused a stir last week when it called for the Bank of England (BoE) to push its base rate toward 5% — warning in its Autumn 2026 Economic Outlook that inflation will not return to the 2% target until late 2030 on current policy.  

The think tank cited a persistent energy shock driven by the Iran conflict, elevated wage growth, and concerns about fiscal credibility as the key drivers. Financial markets are already pricing in a path toward 4.75% by the end of 2027. 

The Bank, for its part, raised the base rate to 4% on 5 November, but its Monetary Policy Committee (MPC) was careful to signal that the move should not be read as the beginning of a series. That distinction appears to have been lost in some corners of the commentary. 

A 5% base rate? Not so fast   

Sebastian Murphy, Group Director at JLM Mortgage Services, is the most direct: he does not buy the NIESR forecast at all. 

"I would be extremely surprised if Bank Base Rate reached 5%, and I certainly don't believe that is where the current MPC is heading. Andrew Bailey and other Committee members have been clear that last week's increase should not be interpreted as the beginning of an inevitable series of rises, and that is an important distinction which appears to be getting lost in some of the commentary." 

Murphy aligns instead with the Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR), which anticipates inflation peaking in spring 2027 and returning to target by 2028. He points to diplomatic signals around the Iran conflict, including growing pressure on Washington to bring the fighting to an end, as a potential turning point. 

"A settlement which allows the Strait of Hormuz to reopen fully and energy prices to fall could fundamentally change the inflation outlook. Increasing UK interest rates will not achieve any of those things, which is why I question whether pushing Bank Rate towards 5% would be an appropriate response." 

Gerard Boon, Managing Director of Boon Brokers, takes a different line. He expects at least one more 0.25% increase in December or January but frames the Bank's challenge as a structural one that rate rises alone cannot fix. 

"It's like the Bank of England is trying to fix a broken water supply by forcing people to reduce their water usage, rather than addressing the fix directly. Increasing the Base Rate will reduce demand, and thus inflation, but it's likely to be at the expense of people's living standards." 

Boon's argument is that the inflation the UK faces is cost-push — driven by supply-side energy shocks, not by domestic demand running too hot. The Bank's rate lever works on demand. It has no direct grip on what happens to energy supply in the Middle East. 

Fixed rates and base rate are not the same thing 

One point the industry keeps having to repeat: when the base rate moves, fixed mortgage rates do not automatically follow. They are priced off swap rates, lender funding costs, and competitive pressure, not off the MPC's decisions alone. 

Murphy makes this point clear: "We have seen a growing number of lenders reducing selected fixed rates before, and since, last week's MPC increase. Swap rates, funding costs and competition all play a significant part in pricing, so it would be wrong to assume every increase in BBR automatically means higher fixed rates." 

The 5% base rate impact 

Rachel Geddes, Strategic Lender Relationship Director at Mortgage Advice Bureau (MAB), does not dismiss a 5% scenario but puts it in context: "A base rate at or near 5% would be a real jolt for borrowers, particularly for those who locked in during the ultra-low rate years and have so far been shielded from the full impact. Lenders would adjust their fixed rates upwards, which would stretch affordability, particularly for first-time buyers and those borrowing at higher loan-to-values. That said, the market has operated at those levels before and adapted."

Murphy's warning is direct to the consumers. Pushing rates unnecessarily high, he says, "could damage consumer confidence and economic activity without addressing the global energy costs responsible for so much of the current inflation." That, for many in the mortgage industry, is the core concern about the NIESR recommendation, not whether inflation is stubborn, but whether the prescribed cure is the right one. 

Get ahead of clients — before the panic starts 

The rate outlook will keep shifting. And brokers can do what they do best: prepare and adjust. 

David Hollingworth, Associate Director of Communications at L&C Mortgages, said: With so many factors at play that could change the outlook for inflation, borrowers will need to think more carefully about the 'what if' scenarios to decide the best course of action for them. That's where brokers will help to bring to life the best approach to protect against the potential for further rate increases whilst highlighting that there's ongoing uncertainty and how that could change again." 

Meanwhile, Boon is blunter about what he expects next year: "There's likely to be widespread panic regarding interest rates in 2027. Our broker team will continue to calm our clients' concerns by being proactive and advising based on their own personal circumstances. I expect there to be a greater need for brokers to stay proactive with client communication to avoid them panicking and contacting alternative brokers or going direct to a lender." 

Murphy offers a note of caution about overreacting to forecasts: "We're certainly not approaching clients on the assumption that Bank Rate is inevitably heading towards 5%, because I don't believe the evidence supports that conclusion. Every borrower is different, and our job is to assess their circumstances, affordability, attitude towards risk and future plans rather than react to every economic forecast or headline." 

Want to be regularly updated with mortgage news and features? Get exclusive interviews, breaking news, and industry events in your inbox – subscribe to our FREE daily newsletter. You can also follow us on Facebook, X (formerly Twitter), and LinkedIn.