Colliers overvalued a shopping centre by millions - the lender still lost

Winning on negligence was the easy part. Proving the rest was impossible

Colliers overvalued a shopping centre by millions - the lender still lost

Colliers got the valuation wrong by nearly £5 million. The lender proved it. The court agreed. And the claim was still thrown out. 

A group of institutional lenders led by ICG proved that Colliers International negligently overvalued a struggling Cheshire shopping centre by nearly £5 million. They proved the valuer owed them a duty of care that covered exactly this situation. They even knocked out Colliers’ attempt to cap its liability at £1 million. 

None of it was enough. 

The High Court dismissed the claim on November 13, 2026, because ICG could not prove what it said it would have done differently with a correct valuation in hand. 

A dated centre in a tough market 

The property at the heart of the dispute was Shopping City, a retail complex in Halton Lea, Runcorn, Cheshire. Built in the 1970s, it sat outside Runcorn town centre, competed with a modern retail park nearby, and was showing its age. Its second floor was vacant and in poor condition. Its anchor tenant, Tesco, had walked out in 2015 and sublet its space to The Range at £2 per square foot - a fraction of its historic rent. The average remaining lease term for the rest of the tenants, excluding Tesco, was under four years. 

ICG had lent £17.75 million to Runcorn One Ltd, a company set up solely to hold the property. The vehicle was linked to prominent property investor Leo Noé and managed by Capreon, a company Noé chaired. Around 40% of the money came from an investment vehicle for the BBC Pension Trust, the remaining 60% from the BUPA Pension Scheme trustee. 

The loan agreement allowed ICG to have the property revalued every 12 months and required the borrower to keep the loan-to-value ratio below 75%. 

A valuation with questions behind it 

In January 2018, ICG asked Colliers to revalue the property. Paul Hale of Colliers produced a draft putting the value at £22.41 million. After his risk department made some changes and he had a conversation with Capreon, the figure climbed to £23.75 million. 

That put the loan-to-value ratio at 74.74% - just inside the 75% trigger that would have forced the borrower to pay down part of the loan. 

The court did not find that the post-conversation increase was separate negligence - there was no allegation Hale deliberately favoured Capreon’s interests over ICG’s. But the final number was well outside what the court determined was a defensible range. 

The true value, the court found, was £19 million. The permissible margin of error for a complex asset like a shopping centre was 15%, making the highest acceptable valuation £21.85 million. At £23.75 million, Colliers had overshot by a wide margin. 

Where the numbers went wrong 

The court identified several failures. The valuation focused solely on the relationship between the rent and the capital value without properly accounting for what the market rent actually was - and that figure was “seriously overstated.” It leaned too heavily on historic sale prices in what the court found was a falling market. It failed to recognise that many comparable sales were local authority purchases made as part of urban regeneration schemes - making those buyers willing to pay above what the open market would bear. And it did not grapple with its own warning, buried in the report’s special remarks, that a sale “would be unlikely to generate maximum value and would only be likely to occur under distressed conditions.” 

Two expert valuers gave the court starkly different pictures. ICG’s expert valued the property at £17.15 million. Colliers’ expert put it at £22.75 million. The court landed at £19 million, considerably closer to ICG’s figure, finding that Colliers’ expert had painted an unjustifiably optimistic picture and leaned on a market index skewed toward higher-quality shopping centres. 

The ‘what would you have done?’ problem 

Proving the valuation was negligent turned out to be the straightforward part. The harder question - and where the case collapsed - was what ICG would have done with a correct valuation. 

ICG’s case rested on a hypothetical scenario: if Colliers had valued the property correctly, the lender said it would have acted fast. It would have told the borrower it was in default, appointed someone to manage and sell the property, and completed a sale by September 2018 - recovering close to the full loan amount. 

The court was not persuaded. 

The problem was ICG’s own track record. When Knight Frank informally told ICG in December 2018 that the property was probably worth only £8.5 million to £9 million, ICG did not move quickly. It dropped Knight Frank’s instruction, went back to the same Colliers valuer it no longer trusted, waited months to send a formal default notice, spent further months negotiating with the borrower, and then entered drawn-out discussions with the local council that dragged on until June 2021. The property finally sold in October 2021 for £10.25 million. 

The court described this pace as “very leisurely.” ICG had to prove it would not have taken a similarly slow approach under the hypothetical scenario, and it could not do so convincingly. 

ICG argued the two situations were fundamentally different - at £19 million, a quick sale would have recovered nearly all the loan; at £8.5 million, the massive shortfall demanded caution. The court found this distinction “arguable, but not so clear-cut as to be probable.” 

Even if ICG had moved fast enough, the court estimated a rushed sale in September 2018 would have fetched only about £11.36 million - roughly a 20% discount to market value in what was becoming a deeply illiquid market. That figure was well below the loan balance, undermining the whole argument that ICG would have sold quickly to recover close to 100%. 

The liability cap that failed 

One finding that matters well beyond this case: the court rejected Colliers’ attempt to limit its liability to £1 million. The engagement was formed when ICG sent its instruction letter and Hale accepted it on January 2, 2018, without qualification. Colliers could not then impose a liability cap in the valuation report itself, delivered weeks later. Had the claim succeeded, the full damages - potentially up to the £4.75 million overvaluation - would have been recoverable. 

What it means for lenders 

For lenders and their advisors, the case is a sharp reminder that proving a valuer got the numbers wrong is only half the battle. The court will measure a lender’s hypothetical urgency against its actual behaviour when trouble arrived - and if those two stories do not match, the negligence finding becomes academic.