Why brokers are missing out on Sharia-compliant buy-to-let

Broker awareness – not customer demand – is the main constraint holding back Islamic finance's next stage of growth

Why brokers are missing out on Sharia-compliant buy-to-let

Demand for Sharia-compliant buy-to-let finance is there. The products exist. The criteria, in many cases, is competitive. The missing piece, according to Rizwan Ali (pictured top), director of sales and marketing at StrideUp, is the broker.

Around half of StrideUp's business currently comes through direct applications rather than the intermediary channel – a ratio Ali describes as the wrong way round, and one he is determined to shift. In a market where thousands of brokers are having hundreds of thousands of mortgage conversations every week, the potential for Islamic finance to reach borrowers who need it remains largely untapped.

"No institution, whether it's StrideUp or anyone else, can have the market penetration the way that the broker network can," Ali told Mortgage Introducer. "There's thousands of brokers, it's just not possible to do that."

Stay ahead of the UK mortgage market. Subscribe to the Mortgage Introducer daily newsletter for broker news, rate updates, and the industry latest delivered to your inbox every morning.

The awareness gap

The barrier, Ali is clear, is not unwillingness. It is not hostility. It is, in most cases, simply not knowing the options exist – combined with a handful of legacy misconceptions that a brief conversation is usually enough to dispel.

Chief among those misconceptions is the assumption that Sharia-compliant finance is a fundamentally different and complicated process. In practice, Ali says, the broker experience is largely the same as placing any specialist buy-to-let case. The legal construct of the product differs – it is structured as a co-ownership and rental agreement rather than a conventional lending arrangement – but that is a matter for conveyancers, not brokers.

"As far as you're concerned as a broker, it's much the same," he said. "It's a two-year fix. It's a five-year fix. It's stress testing. It's affordability. It's rental coverage. Underwriters asking too many questions. It's not distinctively different to what you're doing. You can do this."

The second misconception is that the product is only available to Muslim borrowers. As covered in the first article in this series, that is not the case, and Ali makes a point of establishing this in every broker conversation he has.

A third, more practical barrier concerns FCA permissions. On the owner-occupied side, brokers require specific permissions to advise on home purchase plan products. On the buy-to-let side, however, no such restriction applies. Brokers can submit cases directly without needing any additional authorisation – a point Ali says is poorly understood across the intermediary market.

Brokers are losing business they don't know they have

There is a commercial case here that Ali puts to brokers directly, and it is a straightforward one. Sharia-compliant borrowers who cannot get what they need from their broker will not take a conventional alternative. They will find another route – either through a different broker or directly through a lender.

"If I go to a Nando's and they say this Nando's is not halal, I don't sit there and eat," he said. "I drive 20 minutes to the Nando's that is halal. The consumer is actually quite educated. They've already got the education that there's a distinctive requirement in their needs."

The implication for brokers is significant. A client whose Sharia-compliant needs go unmet is not a client who takes something else – they are a client who leaves. And in areas with large Muslim communities, the volume of business passing through the UK intermediary mortgage market without ever engaging Islamic finance options is, Ali suggests, substantial.

"You're sat in the middle of east London, or you're in Birmingham, or you're in West Yorkshire," he said. "You're sat on a gold mine. There are so many people that will be interested in these products."

He also points to a reputational opportunity that early movers in the broker market have already seized. Because there is still a scarcity of brokers actively placing Sharia-compliant business, those who do develop expertise in the area tend to build a reputation quickly and find that business follows.

"It's a market and a community where you can make a name for yourself very quickly," Ali said. "Once you start doing it, you'll realise very quickly you'll have a lot of business coming to you. This is a whole new stream of income."

How StrideUp is building broker relationships

Around 900 to 1,000 brokers have now registered with StrideUp, according to Ali – a significant increase on where the lender stood two to three years ago. The focus now is on converting registration into active transacting, and on ensuring the service experience brokers receive is good enough to make them advocates rather than occasional users.

StrideUp attends mortgage expos across the country throughout the year and works directly with larger mortgage clubs and networks across the UK to reach advisers at scale. Where brokers are working with clients who have questions about the Sharia compliance structure of a product, the lender also offers to join calls directly, removing a potential friction point that might otherwise stall a case.

The service standard, Ali says, is non-negotiable. A perception that Sharia-compliant finance means slower turnaround times or more complex processes has historically been a deterrent. Addressing that perception – through consistently strong service rather than assurances – is central to StrideUp's broker strategy.

"I don't want brokers to walk away thinking the service is as good as what they could get in conventional," he said. "I want them to walk away thinking this is better than what I get in most places. A Sharia-compliant product should not mean a substandard service. It’s about their customers being happy, they return to us with more business, but more importantly, they become an advocate for this type of finance."

The broader ambition is not just commercial. Ali frames the broker community's engagement with Islamic finance as part of a wider responsibility to their clients – one that the intermediary market, which has always positioned itself as fighting the customer's corner, is well placed to fulfil.

"Brokers should be saying, 'I shouldn't have a client of mine who I can't offer the same type of products that I can to another client,'" he said. "These are the same people who need that voice. They need you to really help bring that financial parity to underserved communities."

Want to be regularly updated with mortgage news and features? Get exclusive interviews, breaking news, and industry events in your inbox – subscribe to our FREE daily newsletter. You can also follow us on Facebook, X (formerly Twitter), and LinkedIn.

RELATED ARTICLES