Mortgage brokers top trust rankings, but some scepticism lingers

New research finds brokers are buyers' most trusted source, but cost and conflict doubts persist

Mortgage brokers top trust rankings, but some scepticism lingers

Mortgage brokers are the most trusted source of home loan guidance for Australians planning to buy property, per new research from the Mortgage & Finance Association of Australia (MFAA).

Yet a stubborn minority of buyers still question whose interests brokers serve and what they really cost.

The Australian Borrower Report 2026, based on a YouGov survey of 2,057 Australians intending to buy within three years, found 30% named a mortgage broker as the single source they trust most. That is double the 15% recorded for both banks and financial advisers.

The findings land as the broker channel sits at its peak. Brokers facilitated a record 81.6% of new residential home loans in the June 2026 quarter, according to Cotality research commissioned by the MFAA.

“Our ambition is to help more Australians move from uncertainty to an informed decision,” MFAA chief executive Anja Pannek (pictured) said.

Why do buyers trust mortgage brokers?

Mortgage brokers top the sources buyers would trust

Share of prospective buyers who would trust each source (multiple responses allowed)

Mortgage and finance broker 58% Own bank or lender 48% Financial adviser 47% Government websites or services 32% Parents or family 31% Independent online research 30% Friends 23% AI tools 19%
Source: MFAA Australian Borrower Report 2026. YouGov survey of 2,057 prospective buyers, 12–24 August 2026

Brokers led every other source when buyers were asked who they would trust for information and guidance, with their own bank or lender a distant second. Among buyers who had used a broker before, 82% were satisfied with their last experience.

“Brokers earn trust by understanding their clients’ circumstances, explaining their options and helping them navigate significant financial decisions,” Pannek said. “This research reinforces the value of that personalised guidance and gives members practical insights into how buyers research, build confidence and decide when to seek help.”

The pipeline looks healthy too. More than three in four buyers would consider a broker, and a similar share said they were likely to use one for their next loan, refinance or purchase – though the MFAA cautions these are stated intentions, not forecasts of market share.

Where scepticism remains

Not every buyer is sold. Among the 449 respondents who would not consider a broker, almost half simply preferred their own bank, while more than one in four doubted a broker would act in their interests or believed one would cost them more.

Bank loyalty is the top reason buyers rule out a broker

Reasons given by buyers who would not consider a mortgage broker (n=449, up to three responses)

Prefer their bank 47% Question whose interests are served 28% Believe it costs more 28% Prefer researching with AI 15%
Source: MFAA Australian Borrower Report 2026. YouGov, buyers who would not consider a mortgage broker, n=449

Those doubts run against the rules brokers are legally obliged to operate under. Mortgage brokers must act in borrowers’ best interests – a legal obligation known as the best interests duty – while lenders generally pay broker commission and any direct broker fee should be disclosed in a written quote, according to the Australian Securities and Investments Commission’s (ASIC) Moneysmart guide to using a mortgage broker.

Scepticism is also unevenly spread. Households earning under $50,000 were almost three times as likely as those earning $150,000 or more to rule out a broker, at 38% against 13%. Rural and remote buyers were more resistant than city buyers, though the MFAA noted that sample was small, at 116 respondents. Downsizers were the least likely of the four buyer groups to expect to use a broker.

Artificial intelligence is now part of the journey for most buyers, but few trust it. While 58% had used AI tools in their buying or financing journey, only 19% would trust AI as an information source, and one in five had used it to prepare questions for a broker.

“Buyers are coming to conversations with more information and questions. Brokers play an important role in helping clients make sense of that research and understand what it means for their circumstances,” Pannek said.

First home buyers – the group the research examined most closely – are the least confident in the market. Only 35% feel confident navigating the home loan market without professional help, compared with 55% of all prospective buyers, yet 86% say they are likely to use a broker.

Putting the findings to work

The MFAA has released a companion guide for members, available in the Broker Toolbox on its member portal, with practical steps in four areas.

First, tackle doubts head-on: explain how brokers are paid, what the best interests duty means and how the cost of using a broker compares with going without one.

Second, engage earlier by letting prospective clients book a conversation before they find a property, and by nurturing those six to 12 months from buying.

Third, work with AI-informed clients by asking what they have already researched, and keep websites and profiles such as the MFAA Find a Broker directory of accredited brokers current.

Finally, communicate for confidence through plain language and written next steps after every meeting.

“We want members to turn these insights into practical action, strengthening trust, supporting informed decisions and demonstrating their value throughout the client relationship,” Pannek said.