CGT rethink leaves property investors sidelined

Business owners and shareholders stand to gain from a teal-backed rethink, but brokers should expect no change for investor clients

CGT rethink leaves property investors sidelined

The Greens have signalled they may send Labor's remaining capital gains tax (CGT) legislation to a Senate inquiry over summer, keeping alive a rival plan from Wentworth MP Allegra Spender (pictured, standing) that would upend Labor’s property tax overhaul.

That overhaul has drawn sustained criticism from the broking industry since Budget night, when brokers began bracing for an investor retreat and warned the changes could shrink housing supply rather than grow it. Labor has since softened its treatment of business assets, a reversal the broking industry welcomed as a win for brokerages, but the property measures remain intact.

Spender has proposed to set the CGT discount at a flat 40% for business assets and shares while leaving investment property on Labor’s inflation indexation plans.

Greens Treasury spokesman Nick McKim told The Australian Financial Review that he had spoken with Spender and that the party was examining her model. "They're very interesting proposals, and we're having a look at those now," he said. McKim added the government's timetable for clearing its budget bills before Parliament rises for the year was not his concern, given the new regime does not take effect until 1 July 2027.

The Greens are a powerful gateway for getting Labor’s legislation passed. With opposition leader Angus Taylor confirming the Coalition would not only vote against the budget tax increases, but repeal them, the minor party holds the deciding Senate votes.

If the Greens force a change to the CGT discount, the government would have to unwind the first tranche of legislation it passed in June.

What the Spender plan changes for the CGT discount

In the May 2026 Budget, Treasurer Jim Chalmers scrapped the 50% discount on assets held longer than 12 months and replaced it with cost base indexation, which adjusts an asset's purchase price for inflation so only the real gain is taxed. A minimum 30% tax rate applies on top. The first tranche of that overhaul of negative gearing and capital gains tax passed the Senate in June with Greens support.

Facing intense pressure from small businesses, the government drafted the innovative business CGT concession (IBCC), a carve-out that requires a business to pass three tests, including being assessed by a government official as "innovative".

Spender would abolish the IBCC and give every active asset, including shares and share options, a flat 40% discount. Passive assets such as investment property would stay on indexation, and the 30% minimum rate would remain. She pointed to Parliamentary Budget Office analysis showing her plan raises about the same revenue as the government's.

The Australian Industry Group, the Australian Chamber of Commerce and Industry (ACCI), independent senator David Pocock and more than 350 business owners have backed the model. "Allegra Spender's proposal is a practical place to start," ACCI chief executive Andrew McKellar said.

Why property investors sit largely outside the fight

For most residential investor clients, the outcome is the same under either model. Established investment property moves to indexation from 1 July 2027 whether Labor's version or Spender's survives. Investors in new residential builds keep a choice between the 50% discount and indexation with the minimum tax.

The exception may be business owners who hold their own premises. If Spender's plan borrows the active-asset test from existing small business concessions, a commercial property used to run a business could qualify for the 40% discount rather than indexation.

A summer inquiry would extend uncertainty that is already showing up in lending data. Australian Bureau of Statistics figures show investor loan commitments fell 8.6% quarter-on-quarter in the June 2026 quarter, against a 2.9% fall for first home buyers.

The longer-term settings are also contested. The Coalition and One Nation have both pledged to restore the 50% discount, and two in three Australians would back a party reversing the changes, according to a survey of 1,018 people by comparison platform OurTop10. The next federal election is due by May 2028.

Industry expectations remain bearish. A Herron Todd White survey found three in four property professionals expect investors to sell or stop investing under the reforms.

Labor holds its ground on trusts

Chalmers' office has privately told Spender it will stick with its current policy, the AFR reported. The government also wants its minimum tax on discretionary trusts through the Senate before Parliament rises for 2026.

The measure, in the Treasury Laws Amendment (Tax Reform No. 3) Bill 2026, would impose at least 30% tax on trust income from 1 July 2028. A Senate committee recommended on 13 November 2026 that it pass unamended. Five industry groups, including the Property Council of Australia, have since urged every senator to reject it, saying about 350,000 small family businesses trade through discretionary trusts.

Many brokers run their businesses the same way. The Mortgage and Finance Association of Australia (MFAA) has warned that restructuring could force brokers to renegotiate lender accreditations and licences.

The Greens have not committed. They want the government to publicly name almost 1 million discretionary trust beneficiaries in return for their votes, and to remove tax exemptions for donations to private schools and religious organisations.

Read more: Trust tax ‘house of horrors’ slammed by business groups and brokers