Why AI isn't replacing mortgage brokers anytime soon

Mortgage advisers and consumers alike continue to have some reservations about the ability of AI to drive the process

Why AI isn't replacing mortgage brokers anytime soon

Almost a third of consumers (32%) use AI before they speak to a mortgage professional, but two-thirds (67%) say the mortgage information it gave them was either not relevant to their circumstances or incorrect, according to research from Coventry Building Society (Coventry) for intermediaries released on 18 November. 

That shows the continuing centrality of human advisers to the mortgage process, and while mortgage professionals say they're also utilising AI to optimise their business, the advice component remains firmly in their own hands. 

AI's main advantage in the mortgage process: speed

Convenience is what draws consumers in. In the Coventry research, 31% said their biggest motivation was that AI is quick and easy to ask, and 14% said they already use it for most of their day-to-day information and research. The result is that some clients now arrive at a first broker conversation having already looked up mortgage terms, likely repayments and how much they could borrow. 

Mortgage professionals are using AI for the same reason. Nicholas Mendes, mortgage technical manager and head of marketing at Charcol, said the firm has been testing it for client contact, from reaching customers near the end of a fixed rate to following up new enquiries. It also supports compliance work. 

“The biggest benefits have been in how quickly we can respond to clients and making it easier for them to arrange a conversation with an adviser, including out of hours,” Mendes said. 

Michelle Lawson, director and personal mortgage advisor at Lawson Financial, uses it to cut paperwork. “I am using it to try and streamline what we do, limit repetition and make our services and documentation more professional,” she said. 

They are not unusual. The Bank of England and FCA’s 2024 survey of AI in financial services found 75% of UK financial services firms already use AI, up from 58% in 2022. 

‘Results are good, but…’ 

The Coventry findings show where the speed runs out. Only a third of respondents (33%) said the information they received was accurate. Some 28% named inaccurate information as their biggest concern about using AI for a mortgage. 

The advisers largely agree, but not completely. Lawson said she is happy with the results about 80% of the time, her own estimate rather than measured data. She said the outcome depends on how clearly she asks. 

“This depends on the prompts and set up used and what you have told AI you want to achieve and how you want to receive it,” Lawson said. “It is a learning curve for me to ensure my requests are clear; it is a learning curve for the AI to also fine tune and hone its responses accordingly to me.” 

That may also help explain the consumer numbers. A borrower typing a first question may not give a chatbot the detail an adviser would collect, though the Coventry release does not test this. 

Mendes said the tools have improved, with a clear limit. “The conversational side has improved considerably, but we use it purely as an aid rather than a replacement for advice,” he said. 

Lawson draws the same line. “I am not using it for advice generation but in a supportive role,” she said. 

This human side of relationship drives the industry. In Mortgage Introducer’s Brokers on Lenders 2025 report, 77% of brokers said past clients are their strongest source of new business. 

The power of personalisation 

The core of the Coventry research is that a quick answer is not the same as the right one. Jonathan Stinton, head of intermediaries at Coventry Building Society, said: “The best mortgage recommendations aren’t generic, they’re personal.” 

Mendes said that the main approach should be built around that. “Everything is built with the adviser at the heart of it, with the aim of making sure we are accessible whenever a client needs us,” he said. “Personalisation is exactly where the adviser adds the most value.” 

Clients appear to see it the same way. A Mortgage Introducer report on the FCA’s Mills Review cited figures showing only 12% of buyers would fully trust a standalone AI mortgage platform, while 30% still prefer advice from a human adviser. The review, published by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA), also found around 26% of UK adults trust general-purpose tools such as ChatGPT for financial advice, despite limited awareness that formal routes to recourse do not apply. 

Stinton’s advice to brokers is to treat AI-informed clients as a starting point. “Rather than seeing that as competition, ask what they’ve found, sense-check it, and use it as a starting point for a more personal conversation,” he said. 

Mendes offers a balanced approach with the use of AI between others in the mortgage industry. He said: "We have seen real progress among mortgage brokers and networks, but the other parties in the client journey, particularly lenders and conveyancers, need to see the same level of investment and development. Only then will the industry have a joined-up environment where communication between everyone involved in a purchase or remortgage is faster, clearer, and more consistent for the client." 

Want to be regularly updated with mortgage news and features? Get exclusive interviews, breaking news, and industry events in your inbox – subscribe to our FREE daily newsletter. You can also follow us on Facebook, X (formerly Twitter), and LinkedIn.

RELATED ARTICLES