A 36% interest rate, a 50% profit share, and a retrial still to come
A Birmingham lender that bankrolled a city-center development is still fighting to protect its share of the profits - six years on.
Sanman Property Management Limited says it lent £1.5 million to 2020 Living Limited to buy and develop a property known as "The Square" in central Birmingham, intended for residential units and a hotel. The loan terms were steep: 36% annual interest and a 50% share of the development profits.
The dispute, filed in January 2021, turns on what happened to those profits. Sanman alleges the borrower and a group of related entities structured a series of property transactions so that the acquisition and sale of The Square showed a loss - wiping out the lender's profit share in the process.
The case has already been through one trial, an appeal, and a procession of interim hearings. At a first trial in October 2024, the court found the borrower breached an implied term of the loan agreement - essentially, that it would not structure the on-sale of the property to artificially eliminate profits and cheat the lender out of its 50% share. Three related defendants were also found to have induced that breach and to have engaged in what the court called "unlawful means conspiracy."
That finding did not stick. The Court of Appeal overturned the trial judgment in February and ordered a full retrial, now listed for March 2027.
The £21.5 million ask
With the retrial approaching, four of the defendants came back to court in August with two requests. The first: that Sanman pay £21.5 million into court to backstop its cross-undertakings in damages - a promise the lender gave when it obtained freezing orders (court orders that lock the defendants' assets in place until the case is decided). The second: that Sanman put up £2 million in additional security for the defendants' legal costs, in case the lender loses and cannot pay.
The fortification bid - the £21.5 million ask - leaned heavily on the evidence of the third defendant, a property developer who operates through a network of special purpose vehicles (companies set up to hold individual projects). An accountant instructed by the defendants estimated the developer's potential losses at just over £33 million, calculated by reference to projected profits from three development sites: 80 Lancaster Street, 211 Broad Street, and Merry Hill. The developer holds beneficial ownership stakes in those project companies ranging from 50% to 100%. The defendants sought roughly 65% of that figure.
The court was not persuaded.
Where the evidence fell short
In a judgment handed down on 17 November the court identified what it called "striking gaps" in the defendants' written evidence and "a distinct lack of supporting documentary evidence."
The central problem was causation - the defendants needed to show the freezing orders, not the litigation itself, were causing their losses. The developer's own earlier witness statements said that if the freezing orders were lifted, the developments and disposals could proceed. That framed the issue as one of delayed profits, not permanently lost profits.
When the developer later argued that lenders were no longer willing to wait and his project companies faced a real risk of administration (a formal insolvency process), the supporting evidence did not hold up. Two letters before action from one creditor were dated August 2025. A final demand from another was dated March. No enforcement action had followed in either case - and the application was not filed until August. The court said it "would expect reasonably current evidence demonstrating that it remains real where administration is relied upon as converting delay into a real risk of very substantial and irreversible loss."
The reputational damage argument fared no better. The developer claimed the freezing orders had so badly damaged the Taylor Grange brand that refinancing was impossible. But the court found no documentary evidence that any refinancing had actually been refused because of the orders. It noted one telling detail: one of the development sites - Merry Hill - had been purchased in January 2024 for £1,879,360 with a £1.5 million lending facility, two full years after the freezing orders were already in place.
The court also pointed to the developer's own October witness statement, in which he said that after the first trial judgment in December 2024, "various lenders were concerned at the Defendants' ability to repay the loans made, which created a domino effect of collapsing several SPVs in the group." That language, the court found, pointed to the underlying litigation as the source of lender reluctance - not the freezing orders.
The fortification application was dismissed.
Security for costs: a different outcome
The security-for-costs application fared better. The defendants were asking the court to make Sanman set aside money to cover their legal bills in case Sanman loses and cannot pay.
The court found the litigation had materially changed since 2023. What began as a "relatively straightforward commercial dispute" had become "intensely personal," satellite hearings had multiplied, and both sides had already spent past their original budgets. The claimants' costs stood at £1,876,298 as of February; the defendants' at £1,810,391 as of August - both above the February 2023 estimates of £1,886,193 and £1,302,871.
The defendants sought £2 million. The court took a broad view, benchmarking against the claimants' revised cost figure of roughly £2.7 million and applying a 25% discount for what it considered out of proportion for a 10-day retrial "largely confined to fact-finding with no expert evidence." After subtracting the existing £1,250,000 in security, it ordered £750,000 in additional security.
The court also knocked out the defendants' claim for counsel's fees for a July case management hearing, noting the application had been delayed four months and filed outside the timeframe directed by the Court of Appeal.
For development lenders watching profit-share disputes stretch into their sixth year, the case offers a practical lesson: freezing orders protect the claim, but keeping them alive means keeping the cross-undertaking in damages exposed - and the other side will keep probing whether you can back it up.