Why HMRC’s incoming powers could derail your landlord clients’ mortgage applications

A new HMRC regime treats innocent tax mistakes as deliberate — and the timing could derail self-employed client’s mortgage application

Why HMRC’s incoming powers could derail your landlord clients’ mortgage applications

Your client asks an AI chatbot how to hold their buy-to-let through a limited company. They never act on it. Under legislation quietly passed after the Autumn Budget, HMRC may now be able to read that conversation. 

That is not a hypothetical. It is one of several new enforcement powers tucked into the Finance Bill that sailed through their first parliamentary reading on 3 November — changes that may change how tax professionals handle their clients, and mortgage brokers are not exempted. 

Correcting a tax error is about to get more dangerous 

From April 2028, every taxpayer who discovers a mistake on an old return will be legally required to correct it. That sounds reasonable but the specific rules make it complicated.  

Under the new Duty to Correct regime in Finance Bill 2026-27, failing to act on a known error — however minor, however innocent — will be automatically reclassified as deliberate for penalty purposes. That is the highest tier in HMRC’s framework, carrying fines of up to 100% of the unpaid tax and a look-back window of 20 years. 

For self-employed borrowers, this creates a timing trap. A client who does the right thing and corrects an old error could trigger a formal HMRC process at precisely the moment they are applying for a mortgage. Lenders treat active HMRC investigations as a risk flag, however minor the underlying issue. An amended SA302 that differs from figures used in a previous application compounds the problem further. 

The document mismatch makes it worse. Self-employed borrowers are legally required to retain records for only five to six years. HMRC’s 20-year look-back window means a client under investigation may be unable to produce the evidence to defend themselves — leaving their tax position, and by extension their borrowing capacity, unresolved. 

Fiona Fernie, partner at Blick Rothenberg, told City AM the legislation “needs clearer safeguards and a finite time limit for making corrections. Otherwise, a measure intended to modernise compliance could undermine it.” 

Your client’s AI history is no longer private 

HMRC already had the power to request digital records during a tax investigation. The Finance Bill expands the definition of “digital information” to cover modern software environments, including AI chatbots — and extends those obligations to third-party software providers. 

The government insists this is a technical update, not a fishing exercise. But as Matthew Greene, partner at Stewarts, told City AM: “People may use AI to explore hypothetical tax arrangements without ever acting on them.” Treating those conversations as evidence of wrongdoing, he said, risks dragging innocent taxpayers into unnecessary investigations. 

For mortgage professionals, the exposure is specific. Clients who have used AI tools to explore equity release, buy-to-let structuring or inheritance tax planning — often before they ever speak to a broker — could find that research surfaced in a tax investigation. The UK government’s own policy paper on the information power reforms, published 13 July, confirms the changes will take effect from Royal Assent to Finance Bill 2026-27. 

Inherited properties could become a liability 

The third change is narrower but no less consequential for brokers who work in probate, estate planning or later life lending. 

Currently, HMRC has four years after a person’s death to request tax information from their family. The Finance Bill removes that limit entirely. A family who inherited a property years ago, settled the estate, and subsequently remortgaged could now face HMRC demands with no time constraint. For clients with mortgages secured against inherited property, the implications for estate planning and conveyancing are significant and largely unexamined. 

Draft legislation does require HMRC to obtain tribunal approval before issuing demands more than four years after death. What it does not require is informing the family until after that decision is made. 

Should brokers fear? 

Not yet, but dismissing these changes entirely would be a mistake. These powers do not need to be aimed at the mortgage industry to land in the middle of it. They work through clients — and clients are shared. That is the more useful thing for brokers to take from this. Not fear, but awareness of what the possibility itself reveals. If HMRC can request a client’s AI chatbot history during a tax investigation, it raises a question the industry has not yet had to answer: how much of a client’s digital financial behaviour sits in a grey zone between private exploration and evidential record?  

If a 20-year look-back window on tax errors is legally possible, it invites a harder look at how well the industry’s self-employed and investor clients have maintained records that mortgage lenders already scrutinise closely.  

If estate investigations can now run indefinitely, it asks whether probate and later life mortgage processes are built to absorb that kind of open-ended uncertainty. None of these are hypothetical problems invented by the Finance Bill.  

They are existing vulnerabilities that the bill has simply made more visible. 

Want to be regularly updated with mortgage news and features? Get exclusive interviews, breaking news, and industry events in your inbox – subscribe to our FREE daily newsletter. You can also follow us on Facebook, X (formerly Twitter), and LinkedIn.