New auction rules see Victorian sellers rein in underquoting

Fewer Victorian sellers are asking for more than their advertised price amid a deepening buyer’s market

New auction rules see Victorian sellers rein in underquoting

Victoria’s new reserve price laws prove one thing: sellers are coming to grips with the emerging buyer’s market.

In the first month of published auction reserves since the rules came into force, the share of properties with a reserve price (the price a seller wants to sell for on auction day) set above the advertised price guide eased considerably.

In introducing the new laws, the Victorian Labor party said: “For too long, Victorians have wasted their Saturdays at auctions chasing homes they were never going to get.

“That ends now. Labor’s Australian-first laws will require agents to publish a reserve price at least seven days before any auction or sale.” The rules came into effect on 1 October.

Property data platform Homer tracked 2,164 residential auctions scheduled across the state between 16 October and 14 November, the first month in which agents were obliged to publish the seller’s reserve at least seven days before auction.

Across the period, 16.8% of reserves sat above the top of the guide, by a median of $29,000. The number fell from 21.4% at the start of the period to to 14.8% at the end.

Under the new rules, agents must publish the reserve price of a property going to auction and update all marketing to match. An auction cannot go ahead if the reserve has not been published a week out. Agents must now also publish the final sale price within seven days of an unconditional sale. Under Consumer Affairs Victoria’s guidance for estate agents, a seller who changes the published reserve restarts the seven-day clock.

The Real Estate Institute of Victoria (REIV) fought the change, which sparked a market transparency row when the reforms were first introduced. The institute pushed instead for vendors to publish a 10% reserve range three days before auction. Its commissioned survey found 94% of Victorian property owners would change how they sell if forced to disclose a reserve a week out.

But the government framed the rules as an end to underquoting, which then-consumer affairs minister Nick Staikos contended was dishonest and unethical.

Homer chief executive and co-founder Henry Pedersen called his firm’s research “promising…obviously that culture and that ingrained strategy is kind of getting peeled back”.

That ingrained strategy Pedersen refers to is to “guide low and watch it grow” – advertising a guide below what the seller wants. This practice is what the rules were built to stamp out. Under the old system, a home might be guided at $1.5 million to $1.6 million, only for the vendor to set a $1.75 million reserve on auction day.

“The frustration there was people were then going off and looking for finance and getting building inspections, and they were never in the game,” Gerald Foley, managing director of Melbourne-based mortgage aggregator nMB, told MPA. “A lot of people were getting severely disadvantaged.”

Homer stresses its data cannot show which above-guide reserves involve this practice, and it makes no finding about any agent or seller.

Not every above-guide reserve price is sinister. A strong campaign can legitimately lift a seller’s expectations: if 30 couples inspect a home guided at $1.5 million to $1.6 million and a few early offers arrive, the vendor could feel confident to get a bit more and set a higher reserve.

The new rules don’t stop that. A home guided at $1.8 million to $2 million could still carry a $2.2 million reserve, for instance – the difference is buyers now learn it a week out rather than on the day.

Vendor expectations being reshaped

Homer’s data lands in the middle of the fastest housing downturn in more than 40 years. Some forecasters warn of a ‘perfect storm’ that could push house prices 15% lower. Cotality’s November housing chart pack shows combined capital city values have fallen 8.1% over seven straight months. Melbourne values are down 7.8% from their November 2025 peak. Over the same period, the Reserve Bank of Australia (RBA) has lifted the cash rate five times this year, taking it to 4.85%, its highest level since 2008. That is a cumulative 125 basis points since February.

Nationally, Cotality’s four-week average clearance rate has fallen to its lowest level since May 2020, and vendor discounts have widened for eight consecutive months to 4.5%.

The auction market was softening well before the reforms. MPA reported fewer vendors testing the market at auction as clearance rates slid through mid-2026, and the downturn later deepened as auctions stalled across the capitals. When the disclosure rules took effect in October, they coincided with a sharp drop in Melbourne auction activity.

Melbourne’s decline is the slowest of the major capitals, with listings 5.3% below the five-year average. But Cotality head of research Gerard Burg has said a recovery is unlikely until buyers regain confidence and borrowing capacity, with rate cuts unlikely before the second half of 2027.

Victoria’s first month of published reserves reflects that cooling. Asked whether the lower reserve pricing signalled a buyer’s market, Pedersen replied: “100%.”

Even where the reserve sat within guide pricing, 41% of auctions ‘passed in’ (bidding failed to reach the seller’s reserve). Where homes did sell, competition was thin. Of 861 hammer sales with a published price, 345 – or 40.1% – sold below the published reserve. That means vendors accepted less than the figure they had advertised a week earlier. The median sale landed just 0.2% above the reserve.

It appears that sellers are adjusting, but not all the way. Nearly twice as many reserves sat above the guide (355) as below it (181). When reserves did come in under the guide, though, the gap was wider – a median of 3.7%, or $35,000.

Foley said sellers were only now catching up with conditions. “I think we’re only just at the point now where vendors are getting more realistic and realising, you know, the world has changed… It’s not the hot market that it was.”

In Pedersen’s perfect world, there would be almost no reserve prices above the guide. “And in this market, obviously a lot of reserves [are] under the guide given the kind of constant downward trajectory the market’s going through,” he said.