Falling property values and tighter serviceability could trap recent buyers, even as Mortgage Choice data shows refi volumes surging
As the major banks move to pass on the Reserve Bank of Australia’s (RBA) latest cash rate increase, refinancing is entering a new era.
Serviceability is being squeezed, monthly repayments are climbing and each rate hike could be the difference between eating well and instant noodles. Unsurprisingly, brokers are witnessing a surge in refinancing activity across the board.
Such is the rate of enquiries that Kapil Virmani, founder of Adelaide-based Think Mortgage, has had to bring in the cavalry.
“I’ve got one full-time broker assistant who is just focusing on managing our existing customer base,” Virmani told MPA. The assistant runs a health check on each loan “to see if we can get them better rates, better products, some better fees and charges, get some cashbacks”.
The demand isn’t limited to his existing book – Virmani’s business took five refinancing enquiries from new customers last week alone.
Yet for all the activity brokers are reporting, many borrowers haven’t received the memo.
Borrowers still standoffish
The latest Mortgage Choice Home Loan Report reveals that only two in five borrowers have actively reviewed their home loan in the past 12 months, even as refinancing volumes through the Mortgage Choice broker network rose 8% year-on-year nationally after five cash rate hikes in 2026.
Borrowers who hadn’t reviewed their loan gave several reasons:
- a quarter cited the paperwork and time involved
- a quarter doubted the savings would be worth it
- one in eight didn’t know where to start
- 19% pointed to break or discharge fees, and 13% to loyalty to their lender.
Brokers came out well. Of borrowers who used a broker to review their loan, 75% said it gave them more options, while 51% of those who went directly to their lender felt their options were limited. More than half (55%) said they would feel more confident switching lenders with a broker’s help.
“The market has materially shifted in 12 months and there could be a better rate or more suitable product available to you now,” said Mortgage Choice chief executive Anthony Waldron.
So what is holding them back?
Why some borrowers are staying put
Richard Brown, a Mortgage Choice broker in Epping, Sydney, said many borrowers simply aren’t tracking their loan. “More often than not, people don’t even know their interest rate or whether it’s competitive.” Last year’s three rate cuts made it worse. With headlines in 2025 focused on falling rates, borrowers “sort of felt okay” and saw little reason to check.
Then there is the paperwork. “It’s always been a case that personal admin and even the thought of getting all their documents together and speaking to a bank is just a barrier that some people just don’t want to deal with,” he said.
But five rate rises in 2026 are starting to shake that complacency. Brown has seen refinancing volumes climb over the past three to four months as rising, rather than falling, rates dominate the headlines. “It’s on the front page, everyone’s aware. So everyone questions themselves and says, ‘am I actually getting the best deal?’”
Brown expects the share of borrowers reviewing their loans to rise as brokers, who now write about 80% of new home loans, manage their clients’ rates. To get past the paperwork barrier, he starts with a five-minute call covering the client’s rate, the property’s estimated value and the loan balance, before any documents are requested. About half of the new enquiries he refinances. For the other half, he gives the client a script to negotiate with their existing lender, which avoids the documentation, exit fees and new application costs altogether. “Quite often the best result is to get a better rate from your current lender,” he noted.
Refinancing can cost roughly $800 to $1,200 depending on the lender, Brown said, and he won’t proceed unless the client recoups that within the first year.
Virmani puts the inertia among borrowers down to a general lack of awareness. “They are thinking, ‘oh, we’ve got the loan and this is it, we’re stuck with the bank and this is how it is’,” he said. His team completes the fact-find over the phone, including after hours, to save time-poor clients the effort.
Meanwhile, some borrowers who want to switch can’t. The Mortgage & Finance Association of Australia (MFAA) found in its August 2026 market sentiment survey that 49.2% of brokers had more clients unable to refinance because of serviceability, more than double the share six months earlier.
Atelier Wealth managing director Aaron Christie-David warns the squeeze is likely to tighten as property values soften.
“With falling property values, we’re actually in a window where it’s going to start to close up,” he said. Softer valuations can push borrowers into higher loan-to-value ratio (LVR) bands and out of the sharpest pricing. At the same time, tighter serviceability means many clients who could have refinanced a year ago no longer qualify.
“Probably at some point next year, a lot of clients may actually become mortgage prisoners,” he warned, pointing to borrowers who bought with less than a 20% deposit in the past two to three years.
His advice, particularly for investors and for white-collar professionals facing job insecurity, is to draw down equity while values hold. “You want to be pulling equity out now rather than waiting for your property value to fall,” he said. Arrears in his brokerage’s loan book have “just started to tick up”, as clients who were “bulletproof at the start of the year” see their savings eroded by those five rate rises.
Refinancing for more than a sharper rate
The brokers MPA spoke to say rate is only part of the story.
Refinancing for a better rate is only around half of the deals Brown is closing. “Probably more often than not, when I refinance, it’s to change structure for a borrower,” he said. That can mean releasing equity, or moving to a lender with more suitable policy, particularly for investors. “I would’ve done more refinancing for restructure than to get a more competitive rate.”
Ethan Tudjman, a finance broker at Cronulla-based FirstPoint Mortgage Brokers, said his clients are also drawing on equity to build emergency funds worth three to 12 months of repayments, to carry them until rates are expected to ease. Some are considering interest-only terms on owner-occupied debt for the same reason. “Cash flow and savings seems to be the most important appetite of clients for us right now (as opposed to just seeking a cheapest rate),” he said.
Tudjman said his business pushes hard for sharper pricing from existing lenders before moving clients. That approach is widespread: in the six months to August 2026, 96% of brokers had helped clients secure a discount from their existing lender, according to the MFAA data on rising refinancing barriers.
Yet for Virmani’s clients, lower repayments are the primary motivation, although some also want to take cash out to pay down other debts. “It’s getting tougher, it’s getting expensive to live on, kids’ expenses are getting higher,” he said, adding that some clients are taking on second jobs and cutting back on eating out. He favours switching lenders, using cashback offers to absorb the cost of refinancing.
He expects the pressure to build. “I think this concern will even get bigger and more serious going next quarter,” he said. “We need to be [on] the front foot educating our customers.”
What else the Mortgage Choice report found
The report, which combines Mortgage Choice submission data with a survey of 1,000 Australians conducted by Honeycomb Strategy in October 2026, also shows how hard households are working to keep up.
Seven in 10 mortgage holders are now making sacrifices to meet their repayments, up four percentage points over six months – a period in which rates rose 75 basis points. Eating out less (33%), cutting back on non-essential purchases (30%) and trimming entertainment spending (30%) topped the list.
“While sacrifices for deposits have remained steady, mortgage holders are needing to make more sacrifices to keep up with increasing mortgage repayments. Mortgage holders continue to show a quiet resilience to manage rising rates,” Waldron said.
Even so, three in four mortgage holders are confident they can keep up with repayments over the next 12 months. That confidence drops to 67% among Gen Z borrowers, who are more likely to carry newer, larger loans, compared with 87% of baby boomers.
Prospective buyers are moving faster despite the pressure, with 33% planning to buy within six months, up from 19% in April. A third plan to share their home with family, housemates or boarders to help cover costs.
Average loan size growth by region
Year-on-year growth in average loan size, Mortgage Choice submission data
Average loan sizes through the Mortgage Choice network rose 6.8% year-on-year to $690,246, led by Western Australia (11.2%), South Australia and the Northern Territory (10.7%) and Queensland (9.7%). Waldron expects that growth to slow. “This year’s rate hikes are reducing consumers’ borrowing power. Together with declining property values nationally, this is likely to slow average loan-size growth across all markets,” he said.