Canadian mortgage affordability worsens in all 13 major cities

Rising fixed rates push qualifying income higher across Canada’s biggest housing markets

Canadian mortgage affordability worsens in all 13 major cities

Rising mortgage rates pushed home affordability lower across every major Canadian city in October.

Ratehub.ca’s Home Affordability Report found that buyers in all 13 markets studied needed more qualifying income than the month before, undoing the brief stabilisation affordability had briefly found its footing in September.

The deterioration was driven by rate movements, not prices. The average five-year fixed mortgage rate among Canada’s Big Five banks climbed 43 basis points, from 4.56% in September to 4.99% in October.

Home prices softened in eight of the 13 cities studied, but nowhere by enough to offset the cost of higher borrowing.

Bond yields drive qualifying income higher across Canada

Hamilton, Ontario, saw the sharpest decline.

“Based on our analysis, a borrower would require an additional $7,460 in income to purchase an average-priced home in the city. This was due to a significant rise in mortgage rates (+43 basis points) as well as a $10,300 increase in the local average home price,” Clay Jarvis, mortgage expert at Ratehub.ca in Toronto, explained.

“The Hamilton home buyer in this scenario would pay $217 dollars more on their monthly mortgage payment, or $2,604 per year, if they bought in October rather than September.”

Toronto buyers faced a $6,680 rise in required annual income; Vancouver, $6,650. Halifax, Montréal, and Victoria also recorded increases between $6,050 and $6,680. Edmonton saw the smallest change, at $1,970.

Jarvis identified bond markets as the central pressure point.

“Rates faced constant upward pressure due to elevated bond yields, which were pushed higher by high oil prices and heightened inflation expectations. While most cities saw home prices soften, the declines weren’t enough to offset the impact of higher mortgage rates and stress test qualifying rate.”

What the rate picture means for buyers and brokers

The Bank of Canada’s third-quarter Market Participants Survey results found that 52% of financial market professionals now view rate risks as skewed upward, with the median five-year Government of Canada bond yield forecast rising 35 basis points quarter-over-quarter to 3.50%.

The best available five-year fixed rate recently dipped 10 basis points to 4.34%, while the best variable rate stood at 3.65% as of November 18, according to Ratehub.ca.

Dr. Sherry Cooper, chief economist at Dominion Lending Centres (DLC) in Toronto, warned at the Women in Mortgage Summit Canada in September that fixed rates are likely heading higher still.

“It is a time when we should encourage anyone that is interested in potentially buying a home that they get pre-approved, because today’s rates, even though they’re a little above what they were last week and the week before, they’re only going higher,” Cooper said.

She added: “We have to expect higher interest rates, which also means that fixed-rate mortgages are very attractive now.”

Home sales fell 0.3% from September and were 10.6% lower year-over-year, according to the Canadian Real Estate Association (CREA).

With the average national sale price just 1.6% below year-ago levels, price declines alone cannot restore the affordability lost to higher rates. 

Make sure to get all the latest news to your inbox on Canada’s mortgage and housing markets by signing up for our free daily newsletter here.