Lender wins $1.39M but loses $623K it forgot to claim

The variation deed was signed. It just never made it into the court filing

Lender wins $1.39M but loses $623K it forgot to claim

A commercial mortgage lender walked into the NSW Supreme Court with a strong case against a personal guarantor - and walked out with $623,000 less than it should have won. Not because the court disagreed with its claim, but because the lender's own court filing left out a key document. 

On November 13, 2026, the court entered judgment for $1,387,469.32 against Victor Kamal, who had personally guaranteed two second mortgage loans advanced by the lender to a company called AK Gardens (VIC) Pty Ltd. The lender, now known as BBMOCO Pty Ltd and formerly called Blackbird First Mortgage Corporation Pty Ltd, was also awarded legal costs at the higher indemnity rate - meaning Kamal must cover the lender's reasonable legal expenses in full, not just a portion. 

Two loans, one guarantee, zero repayments 

The lending relationship started on November 25, 2021, when the lender advanced two secured loans to AK Gardens. The first was for $1,282,295.20. The second was for $105,174.12. Both were structured as deeds of secured loan by second mortgage, meaning the lender sat behind another mortgagee in the queue if things went wrong. Kamal personally guaranteed both loans under a combined guarantee and indemnity deed signed the same day. 

Both loans had 12-month terms. Neither was repaid by November 2022. Neither has been repaid since. In his filed defence, Kamal admitted that AK Gardens defaulted on both. 

The bailout that boomeranged 

Seven months after the original advances, in July 2022, the holder of the first-ranking mortgage over the secured property threatened enforcement action unless it received $516,914.75 in overdue interest. Kamal asked the lender to step in and cover the payment. 

The lender agreed, structuring the bailout as a further advance under the first loan. On top of the $516,914.75, the advance included a $50,000 risk fee, a $30,000 investigative accountant fee, and $2,200 in mortgage variation costs. All three parties signed a Deed of Variation of Loan Facility on July 14, 2022, lifting the first loan total from $1,282,295.20 to $1,905,374.54 - an increase of $623,079.34. 

So far, so well documented. The problem was what happened when the case went to court. 

The gap in the court filing 

When the lender filed its claim in May 2025, it set out the original first loan amount of $1,282,295.20. The variation deed - the document that recorded the extra $623,079.34 advance - was nowhere in the filing. The only hint was a single paragraph claiming $7,824,662.40 as the total owed under the first loan as at May 12, 2025, bundling principal, the further advance, and accrued interest together without breaking them out or mentioning the variation. 

Kamal denied that paragraph in his defence, challenging the total and noting it was "not supported by any calculation, interest breakdown, statement of account, or explanation of the alleged default rate of 4% per month." 

No guarantor, no problem - until the numbers didn't add up 

By the time the case reached trial on November 9, 2026, Kamal was unrepresented. His lawyer, Payne Wu of Hiways Lawyers, had filed a notice of intention to stop acting in August 2026, then formally ceased acting in September. Despite being notified of the hearing date by letter, email, and SMS - including as recently as November 8, 2026 - Kamal did not show up. The court called his name three times at 10:00am and proceeded without him. 

The lender narrowed its own claim at the start of the hearing, dropping its interest claim and enforcement costs and pursuing only the original principal amounts. 

The court had no difficulty finding that the guarantee was enforceable and that Kamal owed the lender $1,387,469.32 - the combined total of the two original loans. That part was straightforward. 

The variation was not. 

The court found that because the lender's filed claim never mentioned the variation deed, it was not appropriate to award judgment for the additional $623,079.34 advanced under it. The court noted it could not safely assume Kamal's approach to the case - including his decision not to appear at trial - was unrelated to the way the lender had framed its claim. Kamal had expressly denied the one paragraph that came closest to incorporating the variation advance, and the narrow framing of the filed claim may well have shaped his decisions. 

The guarantee held up - just not far enough 

The court also considered, on its own initiative, whether the variation might have let Kamal off the hook entirely - a recognised defence under Australian law where a loan is changed without a guarantor's consent. It found this argument would not have succeeded. The guarantee expressly stated it would "extend to and shall not be abrogated or modified by any variation" of the underlying loan terms. And Kamal had personally signed the variation deed. 

So the guarantee survived the variation. The lender's case did not. 

For lenders and their legal teams, the lesson is blunt. A guarantee is only as enforceable as the claims you actually put in front of the court. The lender here documented the variation properly, got the guarantor's signature, and structured the advance correctly - then left $623,079.34 on the courtroom floor because the filed claim did not match the loan file.