Commission scheme costs former BC realtor his licence and $627,000

Regulator details kickbacks, a fake inspection and deleted emails behind the penalty

Commission scheme costs former BC realtor his licence and $627,000

A former Squamish, BC, real estate agent who funnelled buyers to two colleagues in exchange for kickbacks must pay $627,000.

The BC Financial Services Authority (BCFSA) also cancelled his licence in a sanctions decision dated Oct. 28 and made public Nov. 13.

The order against Andre Zubko and his personal real estate corporation stems from a commission scheme he ran across eight home sales in 2016 and 2017. It combines $320,000 in discipline penalties with $307,000 in enforcement expenses.

Zubko’s licence renewal was denied in 2017, and he has not been licensed since.

How did the commission scheme work?

Zubko was licensed from 2006 to 2017 and worked at One Percent Realty, a flat-fee brokerage.

According to the decision, he sent unrepresented buyers to a high school acquaintance and to a cousin of a family member. Those agents wrote offers demanding a higher buyer’s commission, then passed most of it back to him.

Sellers paid more than $50,000 in extra commissions, and Zubko collected $47,641.23 in kickbacks.

Two deals went further. In one, Zubko persuaded a seller to cut the price of a lot sold to his family member from $350,000 to $175,000. The contract was assigned days later for $335,000, a $160,000 gain.

In another, he invented a home inspection to push a price down from $807,000 to $797,000, even though he knew the contract had already been assigned for $845,000.

“It is difficult to imagine a more clear-cut case of deception of one’s client than completely making up a negative home inspection in order to convince that client to sell their property at a lower price,” Senior Hearing Officer Andrew Pendray wrote.

During the investigation, Zubko deleted emails, met with others involved to align their accounts, and gave investigators false statements.

Canadian Mortgage Professional reported the regulator’s original misconduct findings in 2024. 

What the penalty signals for BC brokers

Four transactions fell under the rules in force before Sept. 30, 2016, which capped penalties at $10,000.

For the remaining four, Pendray assessed $550,000, then cut it by 50% to $275,000. He cited proportionality and Zubko’s years without a licence.

He added $35,000 to strip out any remaining profit and set enforcement costs at 65% of the regulator’s expenses.

Zubko had proposed about $85,000 in penalties and $40,000 in costs.

Limiting fines to client losses, Pendray wrote, would turn them into “just the cost of doing business in an inappropriate way, and only if one was caught.”

The ruling lands weeks after BC’s Mortgage Services Act took effect on Oct. 13, completing the province’s overhaul of mortgage broker regulation.

The regulator has also acted against individual brokers, including one barred for falsifying clients’ income records. 

Zubko has 30 days from the decision to appeal to the Financial Services Tribunal and 60 days to pay.

Make sure to get all the latest news to your inbox on Canada’s mortgage and housing markets by signing up for our free daily newsletter here.