Five biggest misconceptions brokers have about lenders mortgage insurance

For many Australians saving for their first home, lenders mortgage insurance (LMI) has long attracted a reputation as an unwelcome extra cost.

But that reputation, according to Greg McAweeney (pictured top), chief commercial officer at Helia, is largely unfounded — and that brokers are well placed to correct it.

"The broker role has evolved well beyond transaction facilitation into trusted, long-term guidance and advice," McAweeney said. "With policy settings shifting and lending criteria becoming more nuanced, brokers need to stay ahead of constant change to deliver the right outcomes for clients."

So what is LMI, exactly? When a borrower purchases a property with less than a 20% deposit — that is, with a loan-to-value ratio (LVR) above 80% — lenders typically require that a mortgage insurance policy be taken out. The premium, usually a one-off payment rolled into the loan, protects the lender in the event of default and subsequent shortfall on the property sale. The borrower pays the premium; the lender is the named beneficiary.

While LMI can pile even more pressure on borrowers trying to buy their first home, McAweeney argues the picture is considerably more nuanced. Below, he takes aim at the five misconceptions he sees most often among brokers and their clients.

Misconception 1: LMI only protects the lender and offers no borrower benefit

While LMI does protect the lender against default losses, brokers should also consider its indirect effect on borrowers. "LMI protects the lender against default risk," McAweeney said. "However, LMI can also indirectly benefit borrowers as it enables them to enter the market sooner, often years earlier than they otherwise could, because a lender is willing to lend to them sooner with a smaller deposit." 

Misconception 2: LMI is expensive and not worth it

The cost of LMI should be weighed against the financial consequences of delaying a purchase. "If property prices are rising, waiting to buy may mean paying more for a similar property later," McAweeney said.

"In those circumstances, LMI may help an eligible borrower buy sooner and avoid the additional purchase price that could result from waiting, where that additional cost may exceed the cost of LMI. This potential benefit will depend on market conditions and the borrower's individual circumstances."

Misconception 3: You should always avoid LMI if possible

Recommending that clients always avoid LMI may not reflect their best interests. "For some borrowers, LMI can be a strategy to enter the market earlier," McAweeney strressed.

"If the property increases in value over time, earlier entry may create an opportunity for capital growth, although outcomes depend on market conditions and the borrower's circumstances."

Misconception 4: All LMI policies and outcomes are the same

LMI is not a uniform product. Policies, risk thresholds, loan limits and assessment criteria differ between providers, and brokers who understand these variations can use them to improve structuring and outcomes for clients, McAweeney explained.

Misconception 5: If a deal doesn't fit standard policy, LMI won't support it

Applications that fall outside standard policy parameters are not automatically declined. "An LMI provider may often take a holistic view of risk rather than focusing on one policy point," McAweeney said.

"Factors such as stable employment, evidence of genuine savings and/or or good repayment history can support approvals, even when the application may not align perfectly with standard policy."

For McAweeney, the common thread running through all five misconceptions is a failure to engage with LMI as a strategic tool rather than a cost to be minimised or avoided. Understanding these differences can materially improve deal structuring and approval outcomes, he argues.

The brokers who do the work, McAweeney says, are the ones best positioned to serve clients navigating an increasingly complex lending environment — and to build the kind of long-term advisory relationships that define the modern mortgage profession.

Want to be regularly updated with mortgage news and features? Get exclusive interviews, breaking news, and industry events in your inbox – subscribe to our FREE daily newsletter. You can also follow us on Facebook, X (formerly Twitter), and LinkedIn.